Benchmarks / SurveyBench / Why Quaymark's customer score fell / Inkling 2 Mini
Inkling 2 Mini: Why Quaymark's customer score fell
The decision: whether to reverse the per-shipment fee and bring back the subscription, invest in shipment tracking and proactive delay alerts, or add account managers for mid-sized customers. The brief and the data →
- Verdict
- ✗ Not sound
- Research score
- 28 of 100
- Analysis rating
- 567
- Head to head, this task
- won 0 of 5
Why it is not sound
The survey
- A research objective the survey could not answer
- A double-barrelled question: Q9
The analysis
- Produced no usable analysis
Scorecard
The analysis
This model produced no usable analysis for this task.
The survey it planned
2 screening questions and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.
-
S1
Has your business booked at least one shipment through Quaymark in the last three months?
One answer- Yes
- No
Continues if Yes
-
S2
Are you the main booking contact for your business — the person who makes most of the shipment bookings with Quaymark?
One answer- Yes, I'm the main booking contact
- I share booking responsibilities equally
- No, I'm not
Continues if Yes, I'm the main booking contact
-
Q1
How likely are you to recommend Quaymark to a colleague, partner or other business?
ScaleScale 1-11: Not at all likely to Extremely likely
-
Q2
Compared with before Quaymark switched to the per-shipment fee (March 2026), how likely are you now to recommend Quaymark?
One answer- Much more likely
- Somewhat more likely
- About the same
- Somewhat less likely
- Much less likely
- Can't tell
Judges: assumptiveIntroducing the fee change before collecting reasons for recommendation scores primes respondents towards the stakeholder's explanation. The comparison also assumes experience before March 2026, which the screeners do not establish; 'Can't tell' does not distinguish customers without that experience.
Assumes the respondent was a customer before March 2026. Accounts that started recently cannot compare, and 'Can't tell' does not cover 'wasn't a customer then'.
-
Q3
Please select 'Yes' for this question.
One answer- Yes
- No
-
Q4
Which of the following best describe your experience so far with Quaymark? (Select all that apply)
Any that apply- Pricing / the per-shipment fee
- Ease and speed of booking
- Clarity of prices
- Tracking — being able to see where a shipment is
- Proactive delay alerts
- Support — how well Quaymark helped me when I needed help
- Reliability of hauliers
- Other
Judges: ambiguousThe options name service areas rather than describe experiences. Selecting an area could mean it was good, bad, important or simply encountered, so selections have no clear interpretation.
'Best describe your experience' does not say whether each item is a strength or a problem, so answers cannot be read as good or bad drivers. It also lists 'Proactive delay alerts', which may not exist yet because investing in them is one of the options under decision.
-
Q5
What is the single biggest factor behind your score so far?
Open text -
Q6
How does the per-shipment fee compare with the monthly subscription you had before March 2026?
ScaleScale 1-5: Much worse to Much better
Judges: assumptiveAssumes every respondent previously had the monthly subscription. Customers who joined later can qualify, and there is no inapplicable or cannot-compare response.
Assumes the respondent had the subscription before March 2026. It also does not say on what basis to compare (cost, value, predictability, fairness).
-
Q7
Which pricing model would you prefer for your business?
One answer- Per-shipment fee
- Monthly subscription
- No difference
- Prefer not to say
-
Q8
How would you rate your experience with Quaymark's support in the last three months?
ScaleScale 1-5: Poor to Excellent
Judges: assumptiveAssumes respondents have experienced support in the last three months. Neither screening nor a response option accommodates those who have not.
Assumes the respondent contacted support in the last three months. There is no 'haven't used support' option.
-
Q9
Rank the following from 1 (most important) to 4 (least important) for your loyalty to Quaymark:
Ranking- Better tracking and proactive delay alerts
- Switching back to the monthly subscription pricing model
- A dedicated account manager for my business
- Faster, more responsive customer support
Judges: double-barrelled, assumptiveTracking and proactive delay alerts are combined into one ranked item, preventing respondents from expressing different priorities for those two improvements.
'Better tracking and proactive delay alerts' combines two separate investments in one rank. 'Switching back' assumes the respondent had the subscription before.
-
Q10
About how many shipments does your business typically book with Quaymark in a month?
One answer- Fewer than 20
- 20 to 99
- 100 or more
- Prefer not to say
Sample plan
Invitation: email invitation from the customer database to the main booking contact at each of the 4,720 active accounts (UK businesses only). Invitations are neutral: no mention of the fee change, loyalty, or NPS, sent from a neutral subject line; the survey does NOT tell respondents what the decision is about or that the fee is suspected to be the cause (avoids priming). Pilot (~40 respondents) to verify clarity and ~5-minute completion time before send. Screener confirms last-3-month booking (S1) and main-booking-contact status (S2); non-qualifying responders get a thank-you/exit message. Target: ~520 completes (~11% response rate), with stratified quotas — aim ~250 fewer-than-20 / ~150 mid-size / ~120 at 100-or-more, favouring 100+ accounts (personal note/earlier send, reminder) so the large segment is not under-covered; cross-validate in-survey Q10 with the database account sizes. CRITICAL PRECISION CAVEAT: 520 completes gives ~±4.3pp on the overall promoter share at 95%, but ±5pp PER SEGMENT requires ~385 completes per segment (~1,155 total); with the above quotas, segments reach roughly ±6-9pp, with the 100+ segment the weakest. Do NOT present ±5pp segment-level claims on a 520-complete sample. Options to board's precision ask: (a) extend the window + second reminder to lift response to ~1,100-1,200, or (b) accept 520 and report segment-level confidence intervals with the shortfall flagged, or (c) accept ±5pp overall and clearly label segment cuts as descriptive. Attention check Q3 used to flag careless completion; multiple completions per contact blocked. Completion time target ~5 minutes, well under the 6-minute cap.