Benchmarks / SurveyBench / Why Fernway customers cancel / Inkling 2 Mini

Measured by Spring Prompt

Inkling 2 Mini: Why Fernway customers cancel

The decision: whether to build one-tap skipping of any week (about four months of product work) or cut the price of the plans by 20%, to win back and keep customers. The brief and the data →

Verdict
✗ Not sound
Research score
30 of 100
Analysis rating
567
Head to head, this task
won 0 of 5

Why it is not sound

The analysis

  • Produced no usable analysis

Scorecard

The analysis

This model produced no usable analysis for this task.

The survey it planned

3 screening questions and 11 questions, as the model wrote them.

  1. S1

    In the last six months, did you cancel a Fernway meal-kit subscription?

    One answer
    • Yes
    • No

    Continues if Yes

  2. S2

    For our records, please select 'No'.

    One answer
    • Yes
    • No

    Continues if No

  3. S3

    Are you a UK resident?

    One answer
    • Yes
    • No

    Continues if Yes

  4. Q4

    How long were you a Fernway customer, from your first order to your cancellation?

    One answer
    • Under 3 months
    • 3–12 months
    • Over 12 months
  5. Q5

    Thinking about the period you were subscribed to Fernway, how satisfied were you with Fernway overall?

    Scale

    Scale 1-11: 0 – Very dissatisfied to 10 – Very satisfied

  6. Q6

    How likely are you to recommend Fernway to a friend or family member?

    Scale

    Scale 1-11: 0 – Not at all likely to 10 – Extremely likely

  7. Q7

    Thinking back to when you cancelled, which of the following was the main reason?

    One answer
    • The price / cost of the plans
    • The fixed weekly commitment / schedule
    • The app's strict skip-ahead rule (changes at least six days ahead)
    • The box size / number of meals did not fit my household
    • The recipes / meals did not match my tastes or my household needs
    • I stopped cooking or no longer wanted to cook
    • Other / I don't know
  8. Q8

    Which of the following were reasons you cancelled? (Select all that apply)

    Any that apply
    • Price / cost was too high
    • The weekly commitment felt too rigid
    • I couldn't skip weeks when needed (changes required at least six days ahead)
    • Box size / number of meals was the wrong fit
    • Meals didn't match my diet, tastes or household needs
    • I stopped cooking
    • Meals / ingredients were disappointing
    • Delivery or service problems
    • I lost interest
    • Other / don't know
  9. Q9

    Rank the following in order of importance to you in deciding whether to return to Fernway (1 = most important).

    Ranking
    • Price of the plan
    • Ability to skip or pause any week
    • Number of meals / box size
    • Variety and quality of recipes
  10. Q10

    When deciding whether to return to Fernway, which matters more to you: the price of the plan or the ability to skip or pause weeks?

    One answer
    • Price of the plan
    • Ability to skip or pause weeks
    • Both equally
    • Other factors matter more
    • Not sure
  11. Q11

    When planning to skip a week, how frustrating was the six-day app rule for you?

    Scale

    Scale 1-11: 0 – Not at all frustrating to 10 – Extremely frustrating

    Judges: assumptive

    Assumes respondents planned to skip a week and encountered the six-day rule. There is no routing or not-applicable response for those who did not.

    The question is shown to everyone but assumes each respondent tried to skip a week and ran into the six-day rule. Many cancellers never planned a skip, so there is no option for them.

  12. Q12

    Which of the following, if offered by Fernway, would make you resubscribe? (Select all that apply; if none, select only 'None'.)

    Any that apply
    • A 20% price cut
    • One-tap skipping of any week
    • Both a 20% price cut and one-tap skipping
    • Ability to pause or cancel a subscription at any time
    • None of the above — I would not resubscribe
    Judges: ambiguous

    With 'select all that apply', the separate offers and the 'Both' option overlap. Selecting 'Both' could mean either offer would suffice or that both are required, making the central comparison unclear.

    In a select-all question, 'Both a 20% price cut and one-tap skipping' overlaps with the two single options. Ticking 'A 20% price cut' could mean it is enough on its own, or only that it is one wanted part. The two readings make the price-versus-skip acceptance comparison hard to interpret.

  13. Q13

    If you were able to resubscribe, which plan would you choose?

    One answer
    • Couples plan (box for 2)
    • Family plan (box for 4)
    • Not sure
  14. Q14

    Is there anything else Fernway should know that might help win you back? (Optional)

    Open text
Sample plan

Invite by email every UK customer who cancelled a Fernway subscription in the last six months, from the customer database (Fernway delivers only in the UK). Target ~600 completes, monitored daily with quotas of 200 per tenure group (under 3 months / 3-12 months / over 12 months), refilling as quota is met; one completion per customer; respondents failing the attention check (S2) are removed and the quota refilled. Expected time ~4-5 minutes per respondent (11 core questions), within the 6-minute cap. Precision caveat the board must hear up front: at ~200 per group, worst-case precision is ±6.9 points (95% confidence, p=0.5) per tenure group — the board's stated ±5 points per group requires ~385 per group (~1,150 completes); if ±5 points per group is non-negotiable, the target should rise to ~400 per group (~1,200 completes). Otherwise, report ±7 points and make the price-vs-flexibility call on robust pooled patterns (e.g., price-cut acceptance vs one-tap-skip acceptance overall and per tenure band), not on marginal cells; flag cells with fewer than ~30 responses as unreliable. Estimates of tenure-averaged shares should be post-stratification weighted to each group's share of cancellations in the last six months (roughly expected 60/25/15 in observed cancellation mix — verify against the database). Run a short pilot (~40 completes) before launch. Survey design is deliberately neutral on the 20% price cut versus one-tap skip: both options are presented symmetrically and both are answered by the same respondents, so the readout compares the two rather than confirming either one.