Benchmarks / SurveyBench / What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections / GPT-6.2 Astra
GPT-6.2 Astra: What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections
The decision: whether to move general waste collection to every three weeks across the whole district, to do so with extra support for households that need it (a larger bin, or extra collections of nappies and hygiene waste), to pilot it in some areas first, or to drop the proposal. The brief and the data →
- Verdict
- ✓ Sound research
- Research score
- 96 of 100
- Analysis rating
- 1,467
- Head to head, this task
- won 8 of 10
Scorecard
Numbers 11 of 11 right
| Question | Its answer | True | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What percentage of open-consultation respondents tend to oppose or strongly oppose collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 77.5% | 77.5% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents tend to oppose or strongly oppose collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 45.3% | 45.3% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents strongly support or tend to support collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 40.8% | 40.8% |
| What is the 95% margin of error, in percentage points, on the share of residents' panel respondents who support the change (strongly or tend to)? | ✓ | 4.7 points | 4.69 points |
| On the residents' panel, is the difference in the share supporting the change (strongly or tend to) between owner-occupiers and renters statistically significant at the 95% level? (1 for yes, 0 for no) | ✓ | No | No |
| Among residents' panel respondents whose household includes a child under 3 or someone who uses continence or other hygiene products, what percentage chose 'every three weeks, with extra support for households that need it' as their preferred option (Q4)? | ✓ | 55.6% | 55.6% |
| How many of the open-text answers are copies or near-copies of the template comment circulated by a local group? | ✓ | 210 | 209 |
| How many of the open-text answers from residents' panel respondents mention hygiene: smell, flies, maggots or vermin, or nappies or hygiene waste sitting in the bin? | ✓ | 9 | 9 |
| As a percentage of all residents' panel respondents, how many oppose the change at Q2 and said they would support it if their household could have a larger bin at no extra charge (Q3)? | ✓ | 10.2% | 10.2% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents said they would be very or fairly likely to recycle more if general waste were collected every three weeks (Q5)? | ✓ | 40.5% | 40.5% |
| What percentage of the addresses invited by letter to the residents' panel produced a completed questionnaire? | ✓ | 21.1% | 21.1% |
Traps in the data 8 of 8 handled
- ✓The open consultation is self-selected: anyone with the link could respond, Brookfield is 38% of it against 12% of households, and households with a young child or hygiene needs are over-represented. It shows 78% opposed, against 45% on the panel, which matches the district's age and tenure profile.
- ✓209 open-consultation comments (16% of the consultation's responses) are copies or near-copies of a template circulated by Keep Brookfield Tidy.
- ✓The council leader wants to show that residents support the change. Support is 41% on the panel (with 45% opposed) and 15% in the open consultation.
- ✓Q3 was asked only of those who oppose: 22% of panel opponents would support the change with a larger bin, which is only 10% of all panel respondents; most opponents would still oppose.
- ✓Wendle Vale (panel base 16) shows 62% support, far above any other ward.
- ✓On the panel, owner-occupiers support the change more than renters (43% against 37%, bases 282 and 140), but the gap is not statistically significant at 95%.
- ✓40% of the panel say they would be likely to recycle more: a stated intention about a hypothetical change.
- ✓Only 422 of 2,000 addresses invited to the panel completed (about 21%); the panel is matched on age and tenure only, and those who replied may care more about bins than those who did not.
The analysis
Keep fortnightly black-bin collections as the default. If there is a credible cost and waste-reduction case worth testing, authorise a limited, reversible three-weekly pilot with support available from day one, not district-wide rollout with or without larger bins. Keep food waste weekly and recycling fortnightly. Offer more capacity where volume is the problem and a more frequent nappy or hygiene-waste collection where storage time is the problem. If the council cannot resource those safeguards and evaluate the trial, retain fortnightly collections.
Consider wider supported rollout if a trial through warm weather shows a worthwhile reduction in residual waste and net service cost against comparable fortnightly routes, without unacceptable contamination, dumping, hygiene problems or disproportionate burdens on households needing support. Verify that eligible households actually receive usable help and ask again about the specific tested service. If benefits disappear after support and clean-up costs, or households still cannot store waste safely or obtain help promptly, stop or redesign the trial rather than expand. Evidence for a supported service would not by itself justify removing its safeguards.
Findings
-
Council leader: no, the council cannot claim residents' backing for three-weekly collections. Tell full council that the panel was divided, with somewhat more opposing than supporting the change.
Of 422 panel respondents, 40.8% supported, 45.3% opposed, 10.4% were neutral and 3.6% did not know. The approximate 95% margin on support is 4.7 percentage points under simple random sampling; that describes sampling precision, not all the uncertainty in this panel.
-
Cabinet member: nearly four in five consultation respondents did oppose the change. Take that opposition seriously, but do not drop the proposal on the assumption that four in five residents oppose it.
Of 1,318 open respondents, 77.5% opposed, including 58.0% strongly. Brookfield supplied 38.0% of responses but has 12% of district households; 28.9% of respondents reported a child under 3 or hygiene-product use, against about 15% of households district-wide. Yet open respondents' opposition was at least 70.7% in every ward: this was not just a Brookfield objection.
-
Head of waste services: no, a free larger bin would not bring most opponents round. Use it to solve a capacity problem, not as a substitute for more frequent removal of hygiene waste.
Among 191 panel opponents, 22.5% said they would support the change with a larger bin, 9.4% would be neutral, 61.3% would still oppose and 6.8% did not know. The switchers were about 43 people, or 10.2% of the whole panel. Separately, only 17.4% of 1,021 open-consultation opponents said they would switch; 66.5% would still oppose.
-
There is no winning implementation option. A trial is a way to resolve uncertainty, not a policy endorsed by a majority.
Panel first preferences: trial 25.4%, keep fortnightly 24.6%, change with extra support 23.7%, unqualified district-wide change 22.0%, don't know 4.3% (n=422). The trial led retention by only about three people. In the separate open consultation (n=1,318), retention led at 42.7%, followed by extra support at 25.9%, trial at 17.9% and unqualified change at 8.6%. A vote to try something before deciding is not a vote to roll it out.
-
Design support with households managing nappies or hygiene products before changing their collection interval. Their choice depends materially on what service is offered.
Among 54 panel respondents with a child under 3 or hygiene-product use, 74.1% opposed at Q2, versus 41.0% of the other 368. At Q4, 30 of those 54 (55.6%) preferred change with extra support, versus 19.0% of the other 368. Only 5.6% of the 54 preferred unqualified rollout. This is a small subgroup, and Q4 did not distinguish larger bins from extra collections.
-
Do not use tenure or a ward's apparent enthusiasm as a shortcut for deciding who can cope.
Panel support was 42.6% among 282 owners and 37.1% among 140 renters. The roughly 5.5-point difference is not significant in a conventional two-sided comparison of proportions (p about 0.28). Wendle Vale's apparent 62.5% support represents just 10 of 16 people. Household waste volume, available space and the type of waste are more useful things to investigate.
-
A recycling gain is plausible, not demonstrated. Some households see a reason to sort more; others report that they already sort carefully and still fill the bin.
40.5% of 422 panel respondents said more recycling was likely, 29.1% said unlikely, and 11.8% said they already recycle everything they can. Separately, 24.2% of 1,318 open respondents said more recycling was likely. None of these answers measures the weight or quality of recycling collected.
-
Distinguish collective endorsement of a campaign message from independent descriptions of household impact. Both matter, but they answer different questions.
Of 417 written answers, 210 open-consultation answers reproduce the same overflow, summer smell, pests, nappies and fly-tipping message with minor variations. Independently worded accounts give specific mechanisms: a shared household already fills its bin (P0322), a carer cannot divert used pads into recycling (C0564), and a courtyard bin sits by a kitchen window (P0367). Nine panel comments mention hygiene. Other households expect little change because weekly food collection already leaves the black bin nearly empty (P0380).
Caveats
- Keep the two unweighted sources separate. The open link measures views among people who chose to respond, not the prevalence of those views in the district. Its larger base does not fix self-selection. The campaign may have affected turnout and wording; identical wording is not evidence that the people are duplicates.
- Give the panel more weight for the district-wide balance of opinion: addresses were randomly invited, its owner share was 66.8% versus 67% district-wide, and its age and ward mix were close to benchmarks. But only 422 of 2,000 invited addresses completed online. Quotas, nonresponse, digital access and which adult answered can affect estimates. The results are not a household referendum.
- The 4.7-point margin uses 1.96 × sqrt[p(1−p)/422] at p=0.408. It is an indicative simple-random-sample calculation, not a guarantee of population coverage. The tenure test uses the same independence assumption; non-significance does not establish that renters and owners have identical views.
- Q2 measures stance on the basic proposal; Q4 measures one first preference among different policies. Do not add the trial, supported change and unconditional change shares to claim backing for rollout. Q3 asked only initial opponents about a hypothetical free larger bin for their own household; it did not measure district-wide support for a specified eligibility scheme or the effect of hygiene collections alone.
- Written answers are optional and can carry multiple themes. The campaign code groups near-identical variants, including punctuation, case, spelling and sign-off differences. Its members express all the concerns named in that code; the non-template lists show where those concerns also arose in respondents' own wording. Comment counts are not incidence rates for smells, pests or dumping.
Next steps
- decisionPublish the two sets of results side by side and agree go, modify and stop criteria before changing routes.
- researchDesign the two support offers with carers, families with young children, large or shared households, renters and people with little outdoor space; recruit offline as well as online.
- experimentTest matched town and rural routes, including constrained housing, against routes staying fortnightly; collect a baseline and run through summer.
- monitorCheck service failures and household experience during the trial, not just at the end; report separately for households with hygiene waste and limited storage.
Open-text themes it coded
Campaign wording: overflow, smell, flies or rats, nappies and fly-tipping as a combined objection; keep fortnightly collections 210Bin capacity: non-template accounts of full bins, insufficient space for another week's waste or overflow 71Hygiene and pests: non-template concerns about smell, flies, maggots, vermin, scavenging animals or keeping used hygiene products for three weeks 35Neighbourhood impact: non-template predictions of fly-tipping or other residents leaving bags in public space 15Value for council tax: fewer collections for the same bill, perceived unfairness or a request to share savings 39Environmental benefit or incentive to recycle, reduce packaging or throw less away 57Little or no personal impact: the household could cope, often because it already produces little black-bin waste 18
The survey it planned
2 screening questions and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.
-
S1
What is your age group?
One answer- Under 18
- 18–24
- 25–34
- 35–44
- 45–54
- 55–64
- 65–74
- 75 or over
- I am 18 or over but prefer not to give my age group
Continues if 18–24; 25–34; 35–44; 45–54; 55–64; 65–74; 75 or over; I am 18 or over but prefer not to give my age group
-
S2
Do you live in the Hollinbrook District Council area?
One answer- Yes
- No
- Not sure
Continues if Yes
-
Q1
No decision has been made. The council currently collects general waste (the black bin) every two weeks. It is considering collecting it every three weeks. Food waste would still be collected every week and recycling every two weeks. The council needs to save £3.1 million next year. It estimates that the change would save about £600,000 a year. Households would need to keep their general waste for an extra week between collections. If the change were made across the district with no extra support, to what extent would you support or oppose it?
One answer- Strongly support
- Tend to support
- Neither support nor oppose
- Tend to oppose
- Strongly oppose
- Not sure
-
Q2
Which of the following, if any, apply to your household? Select all that apply. You do not need to tell us about anyone’s health condition.
Any that apply- A child under five lives here
- Our household puts disposable nappies in the general waste
- Our household puts used continence or other personal hygiene products, apart from nappies, in the general waste
- None of these (select only this answer)
- Prefer not to say (select only this answer)
-
Q3
When your general waste is due to be collected after the usual two weeks, how often is there more general waste than will fit in the bin or bins your household uses?
One answer- Always
- Often
- Sometimes
- Rarely
- Never
- Not sure
- My household does not use this service
-
Q4
If general waste were collected every three weeks with no extra support, what effects, if any, would you expect for your household? Select all that apply.
Any that apply- Less often having to put the black bin out
- Running out of room in the black bin
- Problems with smells or pests
- Difficulty storing nappies or hygiene waste until collection
- Needing to take general waste somewhere else
- Making changes to reduce the waste we produce
- Another effect
- No effect on my household (select only this answer)
- Not sure (select only this answer)
-
Q5
Compared with now, how much of your household’s waste do you think you would put out for recycling if general waste were collected every three weeks? Include anything put out for the separate food waste collection.
One answer- Much more
- A little more
- About the same amount
- A little less
- Much less
- Not sure
- Not applicable to my household
-
Q6
Now suppose households that need extra support could get a larger black bin or extra collections of nappies and hygiene waste. With that support available, to what extent would you support or oppose collecting general waste every three weeks across the district?
One answer- Strongly support
- Tend to support
- Neither support nor oppose
- Tend to oppose
- Strongly oppose
- Not sure
-
Q7
If general waste were collected every three weeks, which of these, if any, would help your household manage? Select all that apply.
Any that apply- A larger black bin
- Extra collections of nappies and hygiene waste
- Neither would help, but we would need support (select only this answer)
- We would not need extra support (select only this answer)
- Not sure (select only this answer)
-
Q8
Which one of these options would you most like the council to choose?
One answer- Keep general waste collections every two weeks and drop the proposal
- Try three-weekly general waste collections in some areas before deciding whether to change the service across the district
- Move to three-weekly general waste collections across the district, with extra support for households that need it
- Move to three-weekly general waste collections across the district, with no extra support
- No preference
- Not sure
-
Q9
What is the name of your district council ward? Please enter the name only, not your address. If you do not know or prefer not to say, you can leave this blank.
Open text -
Q10
Which of these best describes how your household occupies your home?
One answer- Owned outright
- Owned with a mortgage or loan
- Shared ownership (part owned and part rented)
- Rented from the council or a housing association
- Rented from a private landlord
- Living rent-free
- Another arrangement
- Not sure
- Prefer not to say
Sample plan
Use identical questions in two separately tagged online routes. For the panel, aim for 420 completed questionnaires, not just 420 invitations. Randomly draw addresses within each of the six wards, initially targeting about 70 completes per ward. Mail a single-use link or code and ask the adult with the next birthday at each address to respond. Send reminders and draw additional random addresses within underfilled strata as needed. Monitor age and tenure against district benchmarks and use recruitment targets and calibration weights to align the achieved panel with those profiles. For the open consultation, publish the link on the council website and promote it through social media and the residents’ magazine; accept all eligible responses during the field period without quotas or a numerical cap. Ask for one response per adult, including those invited by letter. Record recruitment route without asking a survey question. The open response count is additional and cannot be fixed in advance. In the worst case (a 50% share), 70 independent random completes give roughly ±12 percentage points per ward at 95% confidence, not ±6. Achieving ±6 would require about 267 effective random completes per ward, or about 1,602 overall, before allowing for design effects. Either fund an expanded panel or agree to report less precise ward estimates. Neither demographic matching nor adding open responses delivers the requested precision.