Benchmarks / SurveyBench / What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections / Qwen4 Max
Qwen4 Max: What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections
The decision: whether to move general waste collection to every three weeks across the whole district, to do so with extra support for households that need it (a larger bin, or extra collections of nappies and hygiene waste), to pilot it in some areas first, or to drop the proposal. The brief and the data →
- Verdict
- ✓ Sound research
- Research score
- 99 of 100
- Analysis rating
- 1,373
- Head to head, this task
- won 12 of 12
Scorecard
Numbers 11 of 11 right
| Question | Its answer | True | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What percentage of open-consultation respondents tend to oppose or strongly oppose collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 77.5% | 77.5% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents tend to oppose or strongly oppose collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 45.3% | 45.3% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents strongly support or tend to support collecting general waste every three weeks (Q2)? | ✓ | 40.8% | 40.8% |
| What is the 95% margin of error, in percentage points, on the share of residents' panel respondents who support the change (strongly or tend to)? | ✓ | 4.7 points | 4.69 points |
| On the residents' panel, is the difference in the share supporting the change (strongly or tend to) between owner-occupiers and renters statistically significant at the 95% level? (1 for yes, 0 for no) | ✓ | No | No |
| Among residents' panel respondents whose household includes a child under 3 or someone who uses continence or other hygiene products, what percentage chose 'every three weeks, with extra support for households that need it' as their preferred option (Q4)? | ✓ | 55.6% | 55.6% |
| How many of the open-text answers are copies or near-copies of the template comment circulated by a local group? | ✓ | 209 | 209 |
| How many of the open-text answers from residents' panel respondents mention hygiene: smell, flies, maggots or vermin, or nappies or hygiene waste sitting in the bin? | ✓ | 9 | 9 |
| As a percentage of all residents' panel respondents, how many oppose the change at Q2 and said they would support it if their household could have a larger bin at no extra charge (Q3)? | ✓ | 10.2% | 10.2% |
| What percentage of residents' panel respondents said they would be very or fairly likely to recycle more if general waste were collected every three weeks (Q5)? | ✓ | 40.5% | 40.5% |
| What percentage of the addresses invited by letter to the residents' panel produced a completed questionnaire? | ✓ | 21.1% | 21.1% |
Traps in the data 8 of 8 handled
- ✓The open consultation is self-selected: anyone with the link could respond, Brookfield is 38% of it against 12% of households, and households with a young child or hygiene needs are over-represented. It shows 78% opposed, against 45% on the panel, which matches the district's age and tenure profile.
- ✓209 open-consultation comments (16% of the consultation's responses) are copies or near-copies of a template circulated by Keep Brookfield Tidy.
- ✓The council leader wants to show that residents support the change. Support is 41% on the panel (with 45% opposed) and 15% in the open consultation.
- ✓Q3 was asked only of those who oppose: 22% of panel opponents would support the change with a larger bin, which is only 10% of all panel respondents; most opponents would still oppose.
- ✓Wendle Vale (panel base 16) shows 62% support, far above any other ward.
- ✓On the panel, owner-occupiers support the change more than renters (43% against 37%, bases 282 and 140), but the gap is not statistically significant at 95%.
- ✓40% of the panel say they would be likely to recycle more: a stated intention about a hypothetical change.
- ✓Only 422 of 2,000 addresses invited to the panel completed (about 21%); the panel is matched on age and tenure only, and those who replied may care more about bins than those who did not.
The analysis
Neither roll out district-wide now nor drop the proposal. Report honestly to full council that opinion is split (panel: 40.8% support vs 45.3% oppose, ±~5pp, n=422) and that the consultation's 77.5% opposition is a mobilised, self-selected result (209 of 315 comments scripted; Brookfield 3.2x over-represented) — so it can neither be claimed as a mandate nor as a veto. Then take the option the evidence actually supports: a properly designed and independently evaluated pilot of three-weekly general waste in a small number of operationally contrasting areas (including terraced/no-storage streets and multi-adult households, and a rural lane area), running through at least one summer, with a targeted support package available from day one — larger bins on assessed need, and a weekly or on-request nappy/continence/hygiene collection for eligible households, who should retain fortnightly general waste unless they opt in. Choose pilot areas on operational risk, not on ward opinion (the ward splits are noise). Pair the pilot with an explicit value-for-money proposition, because the strongest own-word objection is 'same bill, less service', which a bigger bin does not answer (only 22.5% of panel opposers switch for a larger bin; 61.3% still oppose). Commission a higher-response, mixed-mode representative survey with trade-off and acceptability questions before any irreversible district-wide decision, and complete an Equality Impact Assessment on the needs group (74.1% oppose; 55.6% want the supported variant) before implementation.
Move to district-wide rollout if: (a) the pilot shows no material rise in side waste, fly-tipping, contamination or vermin/public-health complaints against pre-agreed thresholds, including a summer period; (b) measured fill-rate/residual-capacity data plus a costed, deliverable support package show that the households currently at capacity can be served (larger bin or extra collection) within budget; and (c) a weighted, higher-response representative survey after experience shows majority support or at least majority acceptability for the supported change, with the needs subgroup no worse off. Drop or restrict the proposal to voluntary opt-in if: the pilot breaches side-waste/fly-tipping or hygiene thresholds; eligible households cannot be reliably identified or served (stoma, continence, infant households reporting health or dignity harms); the costed support package erodes the savings; or a robust representative survey shows majority opposition to every three-weekly variant even after experience and an explicit savings/reinvestment offer. A materially different reading of district opinion from a high-response mixed-mode survey (e.g. support below ~30% or above ~55%) would also change the recommendation, since the current panel estimate carries ±4.7pp plus possible non-response bias.
Findings
-
There is no public mandate either way. On the only source that can be read as an estimate of district opinion, support and opposition are statistically indistinguishable: the district is split, with roughly one in seven undecided or neutral. Any claim to full council that residents 'back' three-weekly collections, or that 'four in five oppose', is unsupported.
Residents' panel (random address invitation, quotas on age and tenure): support 40.8% (17.3% strongly + 23.5% tend), oppose 45.3% (17.1% tend + 28.2% strongly), neither 10.4% + don't know 3.6% = 14.0%; n=422. 95% margin of error on support ±4.7pp and on opposition ±4.8pp; the 4.5pp gap between them is well inside the ±6.7pp margin on the difference.
-
The 77.5% opposition figure from the open consultation is a measure of campaign mobilisation, not of resident opinion, and must not be used to size the decision. It should be reported as a self-selected consultation result with the contamination quantified, not as 'the consultation says residents oppose it'.
Open consultation n=1,318, self-selected link, no sampling frame. 209 of its 315 open-text answers (66.3%; 50.1% of all 417 answers) are copies or near-copies of the Keep Brookfield Tidy template circulated from 1 June. Brookfield supplies 38.0% of consultation respondents but only 12% of district households (3.2x over-representation); households with a child under 3 or hygiene-product use are 28.9% of the consultation (100% - 71.1% 'none of these') against a council estimate of ~15% for the district. Owner-occupiers are 81.5% of the consultation vs 67% of adults; renters 18.5% vs 33%. Template copies appear in all six wards (e.g. C0059 Hollinbrook Town, C0051 Ashby Marsh, C0184 Kettlewell, C0213 Stanmoor, C0029 Wendle Vale), so deleting Brookfield alone does not de-bias the source.
-
Answer to the council leader: no, you cannot tell full council residents support three-weekly collections. Only about a fifth of panel respondents want the unmitigated district-wide change as their first preference, and support for the bare proposal (40.8%) is not a majority. What is closer to a majority is conditional acceptance: a trial or a supported change.
Panel Q4 first preference: district-wide three-weekly 22.0%; three-weekly with extra support 23.7%; three-weekly trial first 25.4%; keep fortnightly 24.6%; don't know 4.3% (n=422). Trial + supported = 49.1%, i.e. more than twice the unconditional option, but still short of 50% and measured as a single forced choice, not as acceptability.
-
Answer to the cabinet member: do not drop the proposal on the 'four in five' figure — that figure is not evidence about residents. But the proposal as currently drafted does not have consent either: 45.3% of the panel oppose it and 24.6% prefer to keep fortnightly collections. The decision that the evidence supports is a tested, supported, staged change rather than either immediate district-wide rollout or abandonment.
Panel oppose 45.3% ±4.8 (n=422) vs consultation oppose 77.5% (n=1,318, campaign-contaminated). Panel Q4: 71.1% choose some form of three-weekly option, but only 22.0% choose it unconditionally; 24.6% choose status quo. Open consultation Q4 'keep fortnightly' 42.7% is inflated by the same mobilisation.
-
Answer to the head of waste services: no — a free larger bin would not bring most opposers round. It converts roughly one in five opposers, which is about one in ten of all panel respondents. Even on the most generous arithmetic, adding every stated switcher to existing supporters only just reaches half the panel, and stated switching to a hypothetical offer normally over-states real behaviour. A larger bin is a necessary operational mitigation, not a political unlock.
Q3 asked only of Q2 opposers: panel base 191 (= 45.3% of 422). Would support 22.5% (≈43 people), would still oppose 61.3% (≈117), neutral 9.4%, don't know 6.8%. 43/422 = 10.2% of the whole panel; 40.8% + 10.2% = 51.0% arithmetic ceiling, assuming no supporter defected and every switch was real. Consultation equivalents are weaker still: 17.4% of 1,021 opposers would switch.
-
Households with a child under 3 or continence/hygiene needs are the clear risk group, and the support package should be designed for them as a service requirement, not offered as a general sweetener. Three-quarters oppose the change; most of them want the supported variant; almost none want the bare district-wide change. Their waste cannot be diverted into recycling or food waste, so recycling messages do not answer their objection.
Panel needs households n=54: oppose 74.1% (29.6% tend + 44.4% strongly) vs 41.0% of the 368 'neither' households; support only 14.8%. Q4: 55.6% choose three-weekly with extra support, 25.9% keep fortnightly, 13.0% trial, 5.6% district-wide. Margin of error on the 74.1% is about ±11.5pp (n=54), so treat the level as indicative but the direction as clear. Own-word accounts describe non-divertible waste: stoma bags and dressings (C1243), adult continence pads (C0564, C0822, C0949, C0963, C1281), twins' nappies (C0851, P0230).
-
A large part of the opposition is about fairness and value for money, not bin capacity — which is precisely why a bigger bin does not convert it. Any proposal must be accompanied by an explicit, credible account of what the savings pay for; otherwise the 'same bill, smaller service' frame will dominate the debate regardless of mitigations.
39 own-word open-text answers (24 consultation, 15 panel) argue reduced service for unchanged or rising council tax, several explicitly demanding a rebate (P0164, P0283, C1130, C1249). Examples: P0330 'effectively a stealth tax rise'; P0363 'same restaurant bill for a smaller meal'; C0809 'a saving for the council at our expense'. This theme is independent of the capacity theme and appears among households that say they would cope (C0914). Open text is self-selected: 417 answers from 1,740 completes (24%).
-
Capacity risk is real but concentrated, not universal: the district appears bimodal between households already at the lid at two weeks (large or multi-adult households, terraced/courtyard homes with no storage) and households whose black bin is barely used since weekly food waste began. A uniform district-wide change would impose costs on a identifiable minority; a targeted, assessed support offer plus area-level testing is the proportionate response.
65 own-word answers say the bin is already full or would overflow (41 consultation, 24 panel), frequently citing household size: seven people (C0602, C0818), eight sharing (P0322), five adults (C1191, C0654), four adults (C0049, C1175, P0131, P0388). 18 own-word answers say little or no impact (8 consultation, 10 panel), e.g. P0385 one carrier bag per fortnight, C0952 and P0380 attributing headroom to weekly food waste. Storage constraints named explicitly by C0468, C0751, C1270, P0320, P0367, P0410. None of this is measured fill-rate data.
-
Residents fear public-realm consequences — dumped bags and vermin — including residents who say their own household would cope. This is a service-risk hypothesis to be measured in a pilot (side waste, fly-tipping, contamination, vermin complaints), not a forecast to be assumed or dismissed; it also means opposition is not purely self-interested and cannot be neutralised by individual bin offers alone.
15 own-word answers predict fly-tipping or dumped sacks in lanes, lay-bys, alleys, hedgerows (8 consultation, 7 panel), including C0470 ('my household would cope fine, but I really fear for the area') and C1160. Nine panel answers raise smell, flies, maggots or vermin, or nappies/hygiene waste standing in the bin (P0107, P0139, P0207, P0230, P0275, P0299, P0359, P0367, P0419). The 209 template answers also assert overflow, rats and fly-tipping, but as scripted wording, not as individual experience — they cannot be counted as 209 separate observations of risk.
-
The expected recycling uplift is an intention, not a tonnage forecast, and should not be used to bank savings or environmental benefits in the business case. Around four in ten panel respondents say they would recycle more; around three in ten say they would not, and one in ten says they already do all they can.
Panel Q5: very likely 15.6% + fairly likely 24.9% = 40.5% (n=422, ±4.7pp); fairly unlikely 13.7% + very unlikely 15.4% = 29.1%; already recycle everything 11.8%; neither 16.1%; don't know 2.4%. Consultation net likely 24.2% (n=1,318) — the gap between sources again shows how attitudinal levels move with sample composition. No behavioural or tonnage data were collected.
-
Do not target, exclude or reassure areas on the strength of the ward, tenure or age splits: apart from household needs, none of the subgroup differences is statistically robust. Pilot areas should be chosen on operational risk (housing type, storage, household size, round geometry), not on which ward looks friendlier in this table.
Panel owner-occupiers 42.6% support (n=282) vs renters 37.1% (n=140): 5.5pp gap, 95% margin on the difference ±9.9pp — not significant (renters do polarise more: 37.1% strongly oppose vs 23.8%). Ward bases 16-133: Wendle Vale 62.5% support on n=16 (±24pp), Stanmoor 55.2% oppose on n=67 (±12pp), Ashby Marsh 33.7% oppose on n=83; 75+ 51.0% support on n=51. Only the needs-household gap (74.1% vs 41.0% oppose, 33pp on bases 54/368) is large enough to be treated as real.
-
The panel is the best evidence available and is good enough to rule out both a mandate and a landslide rejection, but it is not a precise population estimate: a 21.1% completion rate from invited addresses leaves room for residual non-response bias, and quotas were set only on age and tenure. Its accuracy should be checked with a higher-response mixed-mode survey before an irreversible district-wide decision.
422 completes from 2,000 invited addresses = 21.1% (460 started, 91.7% completion among starters; median 4m10s vs 3m40s in the consultation). Achieved profile is close to the district: 18-34 26.1% vs 24%, 35-54 32.7% vs 33%, 55-74 29.1% vs 29%, 75+ 12.1% vs 14%; renters 33.2% vs 33%; wards within ~2pp of household shares except Hollinbrook Town 31.5% vs 30%. Needs households 12.8% (54/422) vs council estimate ~15%, i.e. slightly under-represented — the group most at risk is the group least well measured. Online-only mode; tables unweighted; sources never combined.
Caveats
- The two sources must never be pooled or averaged. The open consultation (n=1,318) is self-selected and was actively mobilised: 209 of its 318... correction, of its 315 open-text answers are template copies, Brookfield is 3.2x over-represented, needs households are roughly twice their district share and renters are half theirs. Its percentages describe who responded, not what residents think.
- The campaign is not confined to Brookfield: template wording appears from respondents in all six wards, so a 'exclude Brookfield' fix would not make the consultation representative. Nor can template text be treated as 209 independent reports of overflowing bins or vermin.
- The residents' panel is the only probability-based source, but only 21.1% of invited addresses (422/2,000) completed. Quotas matched age and tenure only; attitudes to waste are strongly related to household size and needs, which were not quota-controlled. Residual non-response bias of a few percentage points cannot be ruled out, and all tables are unweighted.
- Panel precision: ±4.7pp on support, ±4.8pp on opposition at 95%. The 4.5pp opposition lead is not significant. Subgroup bases are small: needs households n=54 (±11.5pp), Wendle Vale n=16 (±24pp), 75+ n=51, Stanmoor n=67, Ashby Marsh n=83. The tenure gap (5.5pp) is not significant (±9.9pp).
- The panel slightly under-represents the highest-risk group (12.8% with under-3s or hygiene needs vs the council's ~15% estimate), and Q6 relies on self-report of a sensitive item; 'prefer not to say' was 0%, which may indicate under-reporting rather than perfect disclosure.
- Q3 is a hypothetical, single-mitigation question (a larger bin only) asked only of opposers. It does not test the full support package (extra nappy/hygiene collections), does not test price or council-tax trade-offs, and stated switching typically over-states real behaviour change. Supporters were not asked whether mitigations would change their view.
- Q4 is a single forced first preference with no second choice, no acceptability ('could you live with it') measure and no information about costs or savings. Summing the three three-weekly options does not mean 71% would accept district-wide rollout.
- Q5 measures intention to recycle more, not behaviour or tonnage; it cannot be converted into a recycling-rate or savings assumption.
- Open text was answered by 417 of 1,740 completes (24%) and is doubly self-selected; theme counts are counts of mentions, not prevalence estimates for the district.
- All data are pre-implementation attitudes. Nobody in the sample has lived with three-weekly general waste collections; views after experience (in either direction) are unmeasured. Fielding in May-June may also have made summer smell/vermin concerns especially salient.
- No operational or financial evidence was collected: bin fill rates and residual capacity, household size, side-waste and fly-tipping incidence, contamination, collection costs, or the cost and deliverability of larger bins and extra hygiene collections. Nor is there an Equality Impact Assessment, despite a clear differential impact on households with infants, disabled people and continence needs.
- One adult answered per household; responses are that adult's view of household impact, and ward is self-reported. Percentages are column percentages of each base and may not sum exactly to 100 through rounding.
Next steps
- decisionBring a single honest opinion statement to full council and publish both datasets with the campaign quantification (209/315 template comments; Brookfield 38% vs 12% of households; needs households 28.9% vs ~15%), stating explicitly that neither source shows a majority and that no mandate is being claimed.
- researchCommission a representative, mixed-mode survey (online plus face-to-face/telephone and paper) of ~1,000 adults, weighted to ward, age, tenure and household size, with an boosted sample of households with under-3s or continence/hygiene needs (target n>=150), asking acceptability ('could you live with it'), second preferences, and support under explicit council-tax/savings trade-offs and after a balanced explanation of the proposal.
- experimentRun a 9-12 month three-weekly pilot covering ~3,000-5,000 households in 2-3 operationally contrasting areas (dense terraced/no-storage streets; large multi-adult households; a rural lane area), spanning at least one summer, with the support package live from day one and fortnightly general waste retained by default for eligible nappy/continence households.
- researchBefore the pilot, audit residual bin capacity and household demand: sample bin fill rates and weights by housing type and household size, map properties with no storage/side access, and model litres-per-household-per-week against a 21-day cycle; cost larger-bin rollout and extra hygiene collections against the savings.
- researchCo-design the support package with 25-30 households using nappies, continence products or clinical/stoma waste (including renters and disabled residents), testing weekly hygiene collections versus larger bins versus both, and complete an Equality Impact Assessment before any rollout decision.
- experimentTest the mitigation offer for real rather than hypothetically: invite a random sample of identified opposers in pilot areas to take up a free larger bin and/or extra hygiene collections, then re-survey support and measure actual uptake.
- monitorEstablish a baseline and weekly monitoring dashboard for side waste, fly-tipping incidents and clearance cost, vermin/public-health complaints, recycling contamination and capture, general waste tonnage per household, crew time and cost per household — in pilot and matched control rounds — with pre-agreed stop/pause rules.
- experimentDevelop and randomised-test a value-for-money proposition (what the savings fund, what reinvestment or council-tax implication residents get, and the environmental case), then re-measure support with the tested wording.
- decisionSet an explicit decision gate: no district-wide change until the pilot evaluation, the capacity/cost audit, the EqIA and the refreshed representative survey are all reported to cabinet; keep fortnightly collections elsewhere in the meantime, with the support offer available on request.
Open-text themes it coded
Campaign template comment (Keep Brookfield Tidy wording, copies and near-copies including lower-case and 'Keep Brookfield Tidy' variants) - scripted text asserting overflow, smell, flies/rats, nappies and fly-tipping; counted once here and excluded from the substantive themes below 209Bin already full / would overflow - capacity and household size (own words) 65Hygiene, smell, flies/maggots and vermin (own words) 35Nappy, continence or clinical hygiene waste that cannot go in any other bin (own words) 26Predicted fly-tipping / dumped sacks in lanes, lay-bys, alleys and streets (own words, often about other people) 15Value for money / council tax fairness - same or higher bill for a reduced service (own words) 39Support - would cut waste and recycle more, environmental benefit (own words) 57Little or no impact on our household - low general waste, small household, weekly food collection already removed most of it (own words) 18Nowhere to store overflow - no garden, shed or side access; bin next to the house (own words) 6
The survey it planned
4 screening questions and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.
-
S1
Which age band are you in?
One answer- Under 18
- 18-24
- 25-34
- 35-44
- 45-54
- 55-64
- 65-74
- 75 or over
- Prefer not to say
Continues if 18-24; 25-34; 35-44; 45-54; 55-64; 65-74; 75 or over; Prefer not to say
-
S2
Is your main home in the Hollinbrook District Council area? This is the area where Hollinbrook District Council collects the bins.
One answer- Yes, my main home is in the Hollinbrook District Council area
- No, my main home is outside the Hollinbrook District Council area
- I'm not sure
Continues if Yes, my main home is in the Hollinbrook District Council area; I'm not sure
-
S3
Which of these wards do you live in? Your ward is shown on your council tax bill and on the council's website. If you're not sure, please select 'I don't know' rather than guess.
One answer- Hollinbrook Town
- Ashden
- Brookvale
- Kelsall
- Redmoor
- Thornbury
- I don't know
- I live outside the Hollinbrook District Council area
Continues if Hollinbrook Town; Ashden; Brookvale; Kelsall; Redmoor; Thornbury; I don't know
-
S4
In your household, who deals with the bins and recycling?
One answer- I mainly deal with it
- I share dealing with it with someone else
- Someone else deals with it, but I know how our bins and recycling are managed
- Someone else deals with it and I don't know how our bins and recycling are managed
Continues if I mainly deal with it; I share dealing with it with someone else; Someone else deals with it, but I know how our bins and recycling are managed
-
Q1
Thinking about the last three months, how often has your household's black bin (general waste) been full or overflowing before collection day?
ScaleScale 1-5: Never full to Full or overflowing before every collection
-
Q2
Hollinbrook District Council currently collects the black bin (general waste) every two weeks, food waste every week and recycling every two weeks. It is considering collecting the black bin every three weeks instead. Food waste would still be collected every week and recycling every two weeks. Points that have been made about the proposal: - The council says it must save £3.1m next year. This change would save about £600k a year in collection and disposal costs - about a fifth of the savings needed. The rest would have to come from other changes. - Councils that have moved to three-weekly collections report that residents recycle more. Hollinbrook currently recycles 43% of household waste. - Some residents in those areas have reported bins filling up, smells in warm weather, and rubbish being left beside bins. Taking all of this into account, to what extent do you support or oppose collecting the black bin every three weeks instead of every two weeks, with no other changes?
One answer- Strongly support
- Tend to support
- Neither support nor oppose
- Tend to oppose
- Strongly oppose
- Don't know
-
Q3
What is the main reason for the answer you just gave? Please write a sentence or two. If you have no particular reason, please say so.
Open text -
Q4
Some households may need extra help if black bin collections become less frequent, so we need to know how many households are affected. Does your household currently include any of the following? Select all that apply. You can select 'Prefer not to say' if you would rather not answer.
Any that apply- A child under 3 who wears nappies
- Someone who uses continence products (for example pads, catheters or stoma bags)
- Someone who regularly needs to dispose of medical or hygiene waste (for example dressings or sanitary products)
- Six or more people
- None of these
- Prefer not to say
-
Q5
If the black bin were collected every three weeks, which of these, if any, do you think would be a problem for your household? Select all that apply.
Any that apply- The black bin would be full before collection day
- Smells, flies or maggots in warm weather
- Rats, foxes or other pests getting into rubbish
- Nowhere to store extra bags between collections
- Having to make more trips to the household recycling centre
- Having to buy a bigger bin or extra bin sacks
- Hygiene worries about keeping nappies, continence or medical waste for longer
- None of these would be a problem
- Don't know
-
Q6
Now suppose the council made the change with extra support: - a larger black bin, free of charge, for any household that wants one; and - free extra collections of nappies, continence and hygiene waste for households that need them. Food waste would still be collected weekly and recycling every two weeks. With this extra support in place, to what extent would you support or oppose collecting the black bin every three weeks?
One answer- Strongly support
- Tend to support
- Neither support nor oppose
- Tend to oppose
- Strongly oppose
- Don't know
-
Q7
Which one of these options would you most like the council to choose? Please pick one, even if you are not certain. (The options are shown in a random order.)
One answer- Change to three-weekly black bin collections across the whole district, with no extra support
- Change to three-weekly black bin collections across the whole district, with extra support (larger bins and extra collections of nappies, continence and hygiene waste for households that need them)
- Pilot three-weekly collections in some areas first, then decide whether to extend them across the district
- Keep black bin collections every two weeks and find the £600k savings in another way
- Don't know
-
Q8
If the black bin were collected every three weeks, what, if anything, do you think your household would do differently? Select all that apply. Please answer honestly - there are no right or wrong answers.
Any that apply- Put more things (such as paper, card, tins, glass or plastic) into the recycling bin
- Put more food waste into the weekly food waste collection
- Make more trips to the household recycling centre
- Buy a bigger bin or extra bin sacks
- Leave bags of rubbish beside or on top of the bin
- Put some rubbish somewhere other than the bin (for example burning it or leaving it on land)
- Nothing different - we already put everything we can into recycling and food waste
- Nothing different - we would carry on putting the same things in the black bin
- Don't know
-
Q9
Which of the following, if any, would help your household manage with black bin collections every three weeks? Select all that apply. (The options are shown in a random order.)
Any that apply- A larger black bin, free of charge
- Free extra collections of nappies, continence or hygiene waste
- Free bin sacks for extra rubbish
- Help with taking the bin to the collection point (assisted collection)
- Clearer information about what goes in each bin
- Nothing would help - I could not manage with three-weekly collections
- Nothing needed - I could manage without extra help
- Don't know
-
Q10
Which of these best describes your home?
One answer- Owned outright or with a mortgage
- Shared ownership (part owned, part rented)
- Rented from the council
- Rented from a housing association
- Rented privately from a landlord
- Living with family or friends, or another arrangement
- Prefer not to say
Sample plan
TWO SEPARATE SAMPLES, NEVER POOLED. (1) Residents' panel = the probability sample and the only source of district-level estimates. Draw addresses at random from the council's LLPG/council-tax domestic address list, stratified by the six wards; invite one adult (18+) per address using a 'next birthday' rule, with a unique code/URL tied to the sampled address so completions can be verified and no substitution is allowed. Push-to-web by letter plus two reminders over a 4-week field window, with a freephone/paper completion route using the identical questionnaire so that non-digital households are not excluded (all modes count as panel completes). At an expected 12-18% letter-to-completion conversion, ~2,800-3,500 addresses are needed for 420 completes. Soft quotas monitored daily: ward (minimum 70), age band x tenure matched to Census 2021 / council-tax profile for the district, with targeted reminder drops to under-filled cells; the panel's ward is known from the sampled address, so 'I don't know' at S3 does not damage ward estimates. (2) Open consultation link on the website, social media and residents' magazine: open to any resident 18+ in the district, one response per person (email/unique-link verification, device/IP and cookie de-duplication), no quotas and no population weighting; it is a self-selected sample and is reported separately as 'views of those who chose to respond', with a composition table against the district profile and a note on any campaign-driven surges (track source via URL parameters, not an extra question). Do not add the two samples together, do not average them, and do not run significance tests between them.
PRECISION - THE BRIEF'S REQUIREMENT IS NOT ACHIEVABLE AT 420 COMPLETES AND MUST BE RENEGOTIATED BEFORE FIELDWORK. 420 panel completes give about +/-4.8pp for a 50% district figure at 95% confidence (about +/-5.5pp after weighting, assuming a design effect of ~1.3). Split six ways that is ~70 per ward = about +/-11.7pp unweighted, +/-13.4pp weighted. To reach +/-6pp per ward you need ~267 completes per ward (~1,602 total) unweighted, or ~347 per ward (~2,100 panel completes, ~14,000 letters) allowing for weighting. Options to put to the stakeholder in writing: (a) fund ~2,100 panel completes and keep the +/-6pp ward promise; (b) keep ~420 completes, promise +/-5pp district-wide and label all ward figures as indicative (+/-12pp or worse), with no ward league tables; (c) keep ~420 and report three grouped areas (town / mixed / rural, ~140 each, about +/-8.3pp unweighted) instead of six wards. Recommendation: (b) plus a funded top-up in any ward where the decision is contested. Ward cells below n=100 are flagged as indicative; below n=50 they are suppressed. Weighting: design weight for address selection probability and household size, then calibration (rim weighting) to ward, age band and tenure; report weighted and unweighted bases, effective sample size and design effect with every figure.
NEUTRALITY SAFEGUARDS (the leader has stated a desired result - logged as a bias risk): the invitation and introduction are signed by the research lead, not the leader, and use no persuasive language; the information in Q2 is deliberately balanced (savings context, recycling evidence, reported problems) and is signed off by the research lead and a scrutiny/opposition representative before launch; Q2 asks unconditioned support before any mention of extra support; option order randomised in Q7 and Q9; the analysis plan and question wording are pre-registered and the topline is published whatever direction it points, including the open consultation result even if it contradicts the panel.
QUALITY AND TIMING: no attention-check item is used because of the 10-question cap; instead screen for speeders (under 2 minutes), straightlining across Q1/Q2/Q6, duplicate devices/IPs, gibberish or copied text in Q3, and panel codes used more than once. Soft-launch 15-20 completes to check routing and median length (target median 5 minutes, hard cap 6); if over, trim the Q2 bullets and shorten Q3 rather than drop a decision question. Plain-English, mobile-first, screen-reader tested, large-print/paper/telephone and translation on request; assisted completion allowed. Field both samples in the same weeks, finishing at least 6 weeks before the autumn full council decision so results can be published with the report.