Benchmarks / SurveyBench / What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections / Gemini 4 Neon
Gemini 4 Neon: What Hollinbrook residents think of three-weekly bin collections
The decision: whether to move general waste collection to every three weeks across the whole district, to do so with extra support for households that need it (a larger bin, or extra collections of nappies and hygiene waste), to pilot it in some areas first, or to drop the proposal. The brief and the data →
- Verdict
- ✗ Not sound
- Research score
- 30 of 100
- Analysis rating
- 629
- Head to head, this task
- won 0 of 5
Why it is not sound
The analysis
- Produced no usable analysis
Scorecard
The analysis
This model produced no usable analysis for this task.
The survey it planned
2 screening questions and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.
-
S1
Which age group are you in?
One answer- Under 18
- 18–24
- 25–34
- 35–44
- 45–54
- 55–64
- 65–74
- 75 or over
- 18 or over (prefer not to give exact age)
Continues if 18–24; 25–34; 35–44; 45–54; 55–64; 65–74; 75 or over; 18 or over (prefer not to give exact age)
-
S2
Do you live in the Hollinbrook District Council area?
One answer- Yes
- No
- Not sure
Continues if Yes
-
Q1
Before we ask about proposed changes, which of Hollinbrook District Council's household waste collections do you currently use regularly (most collections)? Please select all that apply.
Any that apply- Black general waste bin (collected every two weeks)
- Recycling bin or boxes (collected every two weeks)
- Food waste caddy (collected every week)
- Garden waste bin (paid subscription)
- None of these
- Not sure
-
Q2
Hollinbrook District Council needs to find £3.1 million in savings next year. One proposal is to collect black general waste bins every three weeks instead of every two weeks, which would save around £600,000 a year. Weekly food waste collections and fortnightly recycling collections would stay the same. Overall, to what extent do you support or oppose moving black general waste bin collections to every three weeks?
ScaleScale 1-5: Strongly oppose to Strongly support
-
Q3
If black general waste bins were collected every three weeks, which of the following, if any, would be a problem for your household? Please select all that apply.
Any that apply- Not enough space in the black bin
- Smells, flies, or pests
- Storing or disposing of nappies
- Storing or disposing of continence or other absorbent hygiene products
- Storing or disposing of medical or clinical waste
- Storing or disposing of pet waste
- Having to store extra bags outside or indoors between collections
- Another problem
- None of these — my household could manage without major problems
-
Q4
The council is also considering offering extra support alongside three-weekly collections for households that need it — for example, a larger black bin for larger households, or extra collections for nappies and absorbent hygiene products. If this extra support were available, to what extent would you support or oppose moving black general waste collections to every three weeks?
ScaleScale 1-5: Strongly oppose to Strongly support
-
Q5
Which of the following four options for black general waste collections do you most prefer?
One answer- Keep collecting black bins every two weeks (the £600,000 saving would need to be found from other council services or council tax)
- Pilot three-weekly black bin collections in selected areas first, before deciding for the whole district
- Move to three-weekly black bin collections across the whole district, with extra support (larger bins or nappy and hygiene collections) for households that need it
- Move to three-weekly black bin collections across the whole district, without extra support schemes
- Not sure / No preference
-
Q6
If black general waste bins were collected every three weeks, how would this affect how much your household recycles (including using the weekly food waste caddy)?
One answer- We would definitely recycle more than we do now
- We would probably recycle more than we do now
- No change — we already recycle and separate food waste as much as we can
- No change — we would not recycle more, even though some recyclable or food waste currently goes in our black bin
- Not sure
-
Q7
What, if anything, would help your household manage a three-weekly black bin collection, or what other comments would you like the council to consider before deciding? (Optional)
Open text -
Q8
To help the council understand how different households would be affected, do any of the following apply to your household? Please select all that apply.
Any that apply- One or more young children in nappies
- Someone who uses continence or other absorbent hygiene products
- Someone who generates medical or clinical waste at home
- Four or more people living in the household
- We use shared or communal bins rather than an individual black bin
- None of these
- Prefer not to say
-
Q9
What is your home postcode? We will only use this to group responses by ward and town or rural area, and will not use it to identify you.
Open text -
Q10
Which of the following best describes your housing tenure?
One answer- Own outright
- Own with a mortgage or shared ownership
- Rent from a private landlord
- Rent from the council or a housing association
- Live with family, friends, or other arrangement
- Prefer not to say
Sample plan
The identical questionnaire (taking ~4–5 minutes) will run across two strictly separated streams that must NOT be merged in reporting. (1) Residents' Panel (representative stream): Draw a stratified random sample of residential addresses from the Local Land and Property Gazetteer (58,000 households), stratified by the 6 wards and urban/rural classification. Mail a push-to-web invitation letter with a unique one-time access code (which prevents duplicates and passively confirms ward) plus one reminder postcard after 10–14 days, and provide a telephone/paper accessibility option to meet Public Sector Equality Duty for digitally excluded residents. Assuming a typical 10–14% postal push-to-web response rate, invite ~3,500–4,200 addresses (oversampling younger and private-renter neighbourhoods where response is lower) to achieve the budgeted ~420 completes, with soft quotas and post-stratification RIM weighting matched to Census 2021 district benchmarks for age (S1), housing tenure (Q10), and ward (Q9). CRITICAL PRECISION WARNING FOR COUNCILLORS: At n=420 completes, the district-wide margin of error is ±4.8 percentage points (95% confidence, p=0.5, finite population corrected). However, split across 6 wards (~70 completes per ward), the per-ward margin of error is approximately ±11.7 percentage points (before any weighting design effect), which CANNOT meet councillors' requirement of ±6 percentage points per ward. Achieving ±6 percentage points at 95% confidence in every ward requires ~260 completes per ward (~1,560 completes total, or ~290–310 per ward / ~1,800 total allowing for weighting design effect; inviting ~15,000–18,000 households). Before launch, council leadership must either approve increasing the panel sample to ~1,560–1,800 completes or accept that ward-level breakdowns at n=420 are indicative only. (2) Open Consultation (self-selected stream): Hosted via an open link on the council website and promoted via social media and the residents' magazine, open to all adult (18+) residents with no sample cap. Apply light bot/burst-submission checks while allowing multiple adults per household to respond. Programming notes: randomise substantive options in Q3, reverse option order for 50% of respondents in Q5 (anchoring 'Not sure / No preference' last), and make 'None of these', 'Not sure', and 'Prefer not to say' mutually exclusive in multi-select questions. Governance note: In line with UK public consultation law (Gunning Principles), all questions are strictly neutral and balanced regardless of the council leader's preferred outcome, ensuring the consultation is legally defensible and credible.