Compare / Claude Fable 5.1 vs GPT-6 Astra

Claude Fable 5.1 vs GPT-6 Astra

Which is cheaper, which is more capable, and which does better at each kind of work, from 92 results on 11 sources that measured both models.

AnthropicClaude Fable 5.1 Released 1 Sep 2026 · $10.00 in · $50.00 out
OpenAIGPT-6 Astra Released 3 Sep 2026 · $10.00 in · $50.00 out
Claude Fable 5.1 wins 2627 too close to callGPT-6 Astra wins 39

Of the 92 results both models have, the better value on each. Results whose reported ranges overlap are too close to call.

Results as of 16 November 2026 (catalogue release 2026-11-16-49bdfa045dee). See also Anthropic vs OpenAI, every model from both labs.

Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra? The short answer

Pick GPT-6 Astra: it scores higher (Spring Prompt overall 77 against 64) and costs less.

  • Spring Prompt overall: Claude Fable 5.1 64, GPT-6 Astra 77 (out of 100; how the score works).
  • GPT-6 Astra is cheaper to run: $0.037 against $0.099 per product listing on CatalogBench (2.7 times less).
  • They score about the same on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index (53.4 and 52.7).
  • GPT-6 Astra is newer: released 3 Sep 2026, against 1 Sep 2026 for Claude Fable 5.1.
  • On our own benchmarks, on the results both models have: GPT-6 Astra does better for product listings, decks from an analysis and marketing planning.
  • On third-party benchmarks, on the results both models have: Claude Fable 5.1 does better for reasoning and knowledge.

Head to head

64
Spring Prompt overall
77
53.4
Intelligence Index
52.7
$20.00
Price per million tokens, blendedlower is better
$20.00
72
Output speed, tokens a second
72
1,000,000
Context window, tokens
1,050,000

Every fact side by side

Claude Fable 5.1GPT-6 Astra
Price per million tokens$10.00 in · $50.00 out$10.00 in · $50.00 out
Blended (3 in : 1 out)$20.00$20.00
Cheapest host, blended$20.00 (Amazon Bedrock)$20.00 (Amazon Bedrock)
Cost per product listing (CatalogBench)$0.099$0.037
Cached input, per million$0.25 cached input$1.00 cached input
Intelligence Index53.452.7
Spring Prompt overall6477
Output speed, tokens a second7272
Context window1,000,000 tokens1,050,000 tokens
Released1 Sep 20263 Sep 2026 (newer)
WeightsClosedClosed
Developer based inthe USthe US

Prices are the developer's list price where we have read it, otherwise the typical host on OpenRouter; see every model's price. Intelligence and speed from Artificial Analysis.

Which is better for what

Each model's rank among the models on sale today, for each kind of work, from our own benchmarks and licensed sources. Further right is better; the better rank is in green.

Product listingsTurning a sparse product feed and photos into listings that can go live 24 of 32 1 of 32
Decks from an analysisTurning a finished analysis into a deck you could present as it is 11 of 32 2 of 32
Marketing planningPlanning a year of ad spend without overspending 10 of 32 3 of 32
Agents and tool useMulti-step tasks with tools: support desks, coding agents, function calls 19 of 159 4 of 159
Professional workReal tasks from banking, consulting and law, business documents and freelance projects 4 of 51 5 of 51
Reasoning and knowledgeHard questions across science, maths and general knowledge 5 of 187 3 of 187
WritingWhat people prefer in blind comparisons, and judged writing quality 19 of 169 20 of 169
Sticking to the factsSummarising without inventing things, and factual answers 5 of 139 26 of 139
Speed under pressureGood decisions against a real clock (fast chess) 36 of 36 20 of 35

Their slides, side by side

The same brief for both: Manchester store investment review for Hearthside Coffee, an invented company. First slide of each deck from DeckBench.

First slide of Claude Fable 5.1's deck for Hearthside Coffee
Claude Fable 5.1 · deck rating 1,265 · needs work
First slide of GPT-6 Astra's deck for Hearthside Coffee
GPT-6 Astra · deck rating 1,566 · presentable as it is

Every slide, side by side →

From our research

Every shared result

Each model's best result on every measure both have, grouped by benchmark, with the setting that produced it. Under each measure, every model that benchmark has measured is a grey tick, best to the right, so you can see where the two sit in the field. The headline measures of each benchmark come first; the rest are under "Show all". Green marks the better value; where a source reports ranges that overlap, neither is marked.

MeasureClaude Fable 5.1GPT-6 Astra
BulletBench measured by Spring Prompt · 3 results
Cost per game · Blitz 3+2US dollars, lower is better 19 · 18 of 20 measured $0.38 $0.28
Games lost on time · Blitz 3+2% of games, lower is better 9 · 9 of 20 measured 37.5% 37.5%
Invalid moves · Blitz 3+2% of moves, lower is better 1 · 1 of 20 measured 0.0% 0.0%
CatalogBench measured by Spring Prompt · 3 results
Cost per productUS dollars, lower is better 33 · 28 of 33 measured $0.0991 $0.0371
Reliably publish-ready% of products, higher is better 23 · 1 of 32 measured 26.8% 75.0%
Reliably publish-ready · sales brief% of products, higher is better 22 · 1 of 32 measured 5.4% 69.6%
DeckBench measured by Spring Prompt · 3 results
Cost per deckUS dollars, lower is better 31 · 32 of 33 measured $0.81 $1.09
Deck ratingrating, higher is betterThe rating weighs each win by how strong the other deck was; the win rate counts wins against whichever decks a model happened to meet, so the two can disagree. 11 · 2 of 33 measured 1,265 1,566
Accurate decks% of tasks, higher is better 9 · 1 of 33 measured 66.7% 100.0%
ROASBench measured by Spring Prompt · 3 results
Overall scorescore out of 100, higher is better 10 · 3 of 33 measured 51.5 56.6
Audience scorescore out of 100, higher is better 6 · 3 of 33 measured 67.7 68.6
Business scorescore out of 100, higher is better 10 · 4 of 33 measured 52.3 57.5
APEX-Agents reported by APEX-Agents · 1 result
Tasks passed% of tasks, higher is better 3 · 7 of 37 measured 68.6% 64.7%
Arena (formerly LMArena) reported by Arena (formerly LMArena) · 3 results
Overall · TextArena rating, higher is better 6 · 26 of 387 measured 1,501max reasoning 1,477max reasoning
Overall · Text factualityArena rating, higher is better 3 · 31 of 163 measured 1,500max reasoning 1,466max reasoning
Business, management and finance · TextArena rating, higher is better 17 · 29 of 380 measured 1,484max reasoning 1,473max reasoning
Artificial Analysis reported by Artificial Analysis · 3 results
Artificial Analysis Intelligence Indexindex score, higher is better 3 · 4 of 249 measured 53.4max reasoning 52.7max reasoning
GPQA Diamond% of questions, higher is better 8 · 1 of 232 measured 93.7%max reasoning 96.3%xhigh reasoning
Humanity's Last Exam% of questions, higher is better 2 · 7 of 250 measured 59.1%max reasoning 54.7%max reasoning
Remote Labor Index reported by Remote Labor Index · 1 result
Projects done to client standard% of projects, higher is better 2 · 1 of 13 measured 17.9% 20.8%
SimpleQA Verified (Epoch AI) reported by SimpleQA Verified (Epoch AI) · 1 result
Correct answers% of questions, higher is better 5 · 1 of 76 measured 70.8%max reasoning 75.6%max reasoning
UGI Leaderboard reported by UGI Leaderboard · 3 results
Writing score · UGIscore out of 100, higher is better 31 · 13 of 230 measured 63.9medium reasoning 68.9high reasoning
Requested-length error · UGI% off the requested word count, lower is better 8 · 1 of 230 measured 3.0%high reasoning 0.0%high reasoning
Style adherence · UGIscore from 0 to 1, higher is better 2 · 35 of 230 measured 0.43high reasoning 0.38medium reasoning
Vending-Bench 2 reported by Vending-Bench 2 · 1 result
Money after a yearUS dollars, higher is better 22 · 1 of 58 measured $5,422 $15,515
Show all 92 results (67 more)
MeasureClaude Fable 5.1GPT-6 Astra
BulletBench measured by Spring Prompt · 2 results
Ladder Elo · Blitz 3+2ladder Elo, higher is better 18 · 7 of 20 measured 358 839
Median move time · Blitz 3+2milliseconds, lower is better 11 · 12 of 20 measured 5.4 s 5.6 s
CatalogBench measured by Spring Prompt · 28 results
Channel compliance% of products, higher is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 100.0% 100.0%
Channel rules broken% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Channel rules broken · sales brief% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Claims to check% of products, lower is better 22 · 1 of 31 measured 0.6% 0.0%
Claims to check · sales brief% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 31 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Conflicts caught% of conflicts, higher is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 100.0% 100.0%
Content quality% of checks, higher is better 14 · 4 of 33 measured 97.6% 98.5%
Content quality · sales brief% of checks, higher is better 17 · 1 of 33 measured 97.2% 98.9%
Decision accuracy% of decisions, higher is better 22 · 4 of 33 measured 95.9% 98.5%
Failed outputs% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Failed outputs · sales brief% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Field accuracy% of missing fields, higher is better 6 · 13 of 33 measured 94.7% 94.2%
Invented values% of filled values, lower is better 7 · 22 of 33 measured 0.7% 1.9%
Missing UK information% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Missing UK information · sales brief% of products, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Not findable% of products, lower is better 5 · 23 of 33 measured 1.8% 6.0%
Not findable · sales brief% of products, lower is better 5 · 22 of 33 measured 1.8% 5.4%
Publish-ready listings% of products, higher is better 24 · 4 of 33 measured 46.4% 77.4%
Publish-ready listings · sales brief% of products, higher is better 25 · 4 of 33 measured 13.7% 73.2%
Time per productseconds, lower is better 22 · 15 of 33 measured 21.7 12.3
Unsupported claims% of products, lower is better 30 · 4 of 33 measured 48.8% 1.2%
Unsupported claimsclaims per product, lower is better 29 · 3 of 33 measured 1.23 0.02
Unsupported claims · sales brief% of products, lower is better 30 · 3 of 33 measured 83.9% 2.4%
Unsupported claims · sales briefclaims per product, lower is better 29 · 1 of 33 measured 3.86 0.05
Wrong attributes% of products, lower is better 3 · 19 of 33 measured 11.9% 17.3%
Wrong attributes · sales brief% of products, lower is better 10 · 23 of 33 measured 14.9% 20.2%
Wrong category or variant% of products, lower is better 20 · 6 of 33 measured 2.4% 1.8%
Wrong category or variant · sales brief% of products, lower is better 6 · 6 of 33 measured 1.8% 1.8%
DeckBench measured by Spring Prompt · 14 results
Caveat dropped% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Clean layout% of tasks, higher is better 16 · 1 of 33 measured 33.3% 100.0%
Design quality% of the maximum, higher is better 18 · 1 of 33 measured 66.6% 88.5%
Draft figure quoted% of tasks, lower is better 19 · 1 of 33 measured 33.3% 0.0%
Findings missing% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Head-to-head win rate% of comparisons, higher is betterThe rating weighs each win by how strong the other deck was; the win rate counts wins against whichever decks a model happened to meet, so the two can disagree. 8 · 1 of 33 measured 74.7% 89.7%
Layout defects% of tasks, lower is better 16 · 1 of 33 measured 66.7% 0.0%
Misleading metric used% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Presentable decks% of tasks, higher is better 7 · 2 of 33 measured 33.3% 66.7%
Recommendation late or wrong% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Slides needing work% of tasks, lower is better 17 · 10 of 33 measured 50.0% 33.3%
Time per deckseconds, lower is better 19 · 27 of 33 measured 158 311
Unsupported claims% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
Unsupported numbers% of tasks, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0.0% 0.0%
ROASBench measured by Spring Prompt · 6 results
Consistency scorescore out of 100, higher is better 12 · 2 of 33 measured 33.3 44.7
Contribution profitsimulated US dollars, higher is better 2 · 18 of 33 measured $965,271 $599,139
Cost of a runUS dollars, lower is better 33 · 30 of 33 measured $2.49 $1.23
Months over budgetmonths of 12, lower is better 1 · 1 of 33 measured 0 0
Planning scorescore out of 100, higher is better 24 · 11 of 33 measured 54.6 54.9
Return on ad spendprofit per $1 spent, higher is better 13 · 8 of 33 measured $0.64 $0.67
Arena (formerly LMArena) reported by Arena (formerly LMArena) · 9 results
Confirmed task success · AgentIPS effect estimate, higher is better 1 · 6 of 48 measured 0.18max reasoning, arena agent 0.13max reasoning, arena agent
Creative writing · TextArena rating, higher is better 9 · 32 of 385 measured 1,482max reasoning 1,449max reasoning
Expert prompts · TextArena rating, higher is better 15 · 17 of 338 measured 1,521max reasoning 1,517max reasoning
Instruction following · TextArena rating, higher is better 6 · 24 of 387 measured 1,497max reasoning 1,474max reasoning
Overall · DocumentArena rating, higher is better 4 · 13 of 38 measured 1,493max reasoning 1,473max reasoning
Praise over complaint · AgentIPS effect estimate, higher is better 2 · 1 of 48 measured 0.32max reasoning, arena agent 0.35max reasoning, arena agent
Steerability · AgentIPS effect estimate, higher is better 6 · 7 of 48 measured 0.09max reasoning, arena agent 0.08max reasoning, arena agent
Tool grounding · AgentIPS effect estimate, higher is better 4 · 13 of 48 measured 0.00max reasoning, arena agent 0.00max reasoning, arena agent
Writing, literature and language · TextArena rating, higher is better 7 · 24 of 386 measured 1,491max reasoning 1,465max reasoning
Artificial Analysis reported by Artificial Analysis · 8 results
Terminal-Bench 2.1% of tasks, higher is better 1 · 2 of 131 measured 91.4%max reasoning 89.9%high reasoning
Terminal-Bench 4.0% of tasks, higher is better 8 · 3 of 120 measured 55.1%xhigh reasoning 59.6%xhigh reasoning
τ-bench banking% of tasks, higher is better 8 · 15 of 121 measured 47.2%max reasoning 43.1%xhigh reasoning
Artificial Analysis Coding Indexindex score, higher is better 1 · 4 of 130 measured 81.6max reasoning 77.1high reasoning
Long-context reasoning (AA-LCR)% of questions, higher is better 4 · 36 of 241 measured 85.3%max reasoning 80.7%max reasoning
Output speedtokens per second, higher is better 58 · 59 of 78 measured 72.5max reasoning 71.7max reasoning
SciCode% of problems, higher is better 2 · 21 of 121 measured 63.1%max reasoning 56.5%max reasoning
Time to first answer tokenseconds, lower is better 24 · 33 of 78 measured 0.92low reasoning 1.41low reasoning

Quick answers

Is Claude Fable 5.1 better than GPT-6 Astra?

Pick GPT-6 Astra: it scores higher (Spring Prompt overall 77 against 64) and costs less.

Which is cheaper, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra is cheaper to run: $0.037 against $0.099 per product listing on CatalogBench (2.7 times less).

Which is faster, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

Claude Fable 5.1 writes about 72 tokens a second on its usual API, against 72 for GPT-6 Astra (Artificial Analysis).

Which is better for product listings, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra ranks 1 of 32 models on sale for turning a sparse product feed and photos into listings that can go live, against 24 for Claude Fable 5.1.

Which is better for decks from an analysis, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra ranks 2 of 32 models on sale for turning a finished analysis into a deck you could present as it is, against 11 for Claude Fable 5.1.

Which is better for marketing planning, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra ranks 3 of 32 models on sale for planning a year of ad spend without overspending, against 10 for Claude Fable 5.1.

Which is better for agents and tool use, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra ranks 4 of 159 models on sale for multi-step tasks with tools: support desks, coding agents, function calls, against 19 for Claude Fable 5.1.

Which has the bigger context window, Claude Fable 5.1 or GPT-6 Astra?

GPT-6 Astra: 1,050,000 tokens, against 1,000,000 for Claude Fable 5.1.

Run Claude Fable 5.1 and GPT-6 Astra on your own prompt.

Benchmarks aren't your task. Test both side by side on your prompt, with every answer checked against your rules and the cost of each one.