Benchmarks / SurveyBench / Should Corefit gyms stop opening 24 hours? / GPT-6.2 Sol

Measured by Spring Prompt

GPT-6.2 Sol: Should Corefit gyms stop opening 24 hours?

The decision: whether to close all 14 gyms between 11pm and 5am, close overnight only at the quietest gyms, or keep every gym open 24 hours. The brief and the data →

Verdict
✗ Not sound
Research score
30 of 100
Analysis rating
1,354
Head to head, this task
won 7 of 11

Why it is not sound

The analysis

  • Produced no usable analysis

Scorecard

The analysis

Recommendation

Keep all 14 gyms open 24 hours for now. If site records confirm low overnight demand, meaningful avoidable costs and a workable overnight alternative for affected members, run a reversible 11pm–5am closure pilot at a small number of those sites. Do not roll out chain-wide or set policy by region. Make site hours and alternative access clear before any pilot; extend selective closures only where observed savings outweigh the losses and member impacts.

What would change it

Move to selective closure if a controlled pilot shows sustained net savings after incremental churn, changes in sign-ups, concessions and implementation costs, with acceptable effects on overnight-dependent members and on crowding. Keep sites open where savings are negligible, there is no practical alternative, or harms exceed agreed limits. Consider chain-wide closure only if comparable evidence shows it is preferable even at the sites with the greatest overnight dependence and after accounting for the loss of the 24-hour brand promise.

Findings

  1. Operations: Overnight use is a minority behaviour, but the evidence does not justify closing all 14 gyms. The chain-wide share tells us neither how quiet each site is nor what it would save by closing.

    High confidenceBase 950

    September door records show that 6% of current members, about 2,316, entered overnight at least once. In the survey, 142 of 950 (14.9%) reported being in a gym overnight in the last four weeks, while 5.4% usually arrived overnight. Among the 142 overnight users, the median was in the 2–3 visit band and the mean was 7.4 visits: some used the hours much more often than others.

  2. Marketing: We cannot forecast how many members will leave. About 4,400 is a projection of stated cancellation intent under a specific weighting assumption, not a forecast of additional cancellations.

    Medium confidenceBase 950

    Overall, 14.6% said they were fairly or very likely to cancel, including 6.1% who said very likely. The combined figure was 45.8% among overnight users (n=142) and 9.2% among other respondents (n=808). Using the displayed rates, 0.06 × 45.8% + 0.94 × 9.2% = 11.396%, or about 4,399 of 38,600 members. This adjusts the mix of users and non-users, not the reliability of their stated intentions.

  3. 24-hour opening has value beyond recent use. A closure could change perceptions of value among members who still train at the same times.

    Medium confidenceBase 950

    24.0% selected 24-hour opening as one reason for joining, compared with 68.9% for price and 62.6% for proximity. It was selected by 59.2% of overnight users (n=142) and 17.8% of non-users (n=808). Some non-users explicitly expected lower fees; others anticipated crowding just before 11pm or after 5am. Neither effect has been measured in practice.

  4. Protect access for members whose shifts leave them no workable alternative. Low average use does not mean low impact on those members.

    Medium confidenceBase 56

    Among respondents whose shifts include nights (n=56), 80.4% reported overnight use, 62.5% usually arrived overnight, and 48.2% said they were likely to cancel. In 16 comments, respondents said shift or night work made overnight their only training window. Nineteen comments from recent overnight users indicated they would switch, or would probably switch, to another gym.

  5. Regional management: Do not give the North West a blanket exemption or assume it is safe to close in the North East. The regional result is a reason to investigate sites, not to set regional policy.

    Medium confidenceBase 449

    Stated cancellation intent was 19.2% in the North West (n=229) and 13.6% in the North East (n=220), a 5.6-point gap that was not significant in a two-sided two-proportion test (p≈0.11; approximate 95% interval for the gap: −1.3 to +12.4 points). Recent overnight use was similar, at 14.0% and 15.0%. Within the North East, Newcastle Byker was at 18.9% likely to cancel and Middlesbrough Centre at 8.6%.

  6. Use site-level survey results to shortlist checks, not to pick closures. A low reported usage rate and low cancellation intent do not always go together.

    Low confidenceBase 250

    Leeds Kirkstall (n=80) was at 7.5% for reported overnight use and 8.8% for likely cancellation; Middlesbrough Centre (n=81) was at 9.9% and 8.6%. Preston Centre (n=78) had similarly low reported use (7.7%) but higher stated cancellation intent (19.2%). Wakefield's 54.5% overnight-use figure represents just 6 of 11 respondents. Q1 measures use of any Corefit gym, not necessarily the registered home site.

Caveats

  • 950 of 11,900 invitees completed the survey (8.0%). Random invitations do not make the completes representative. The ±2.3 percentage-point margin is a nominal 95% simple-random-sample calculation for the unweighted overnight share; it does not account for nonresponse, reporting error or measurement differences.
  • The 6% benchmark is based on September entries during the window; Q1 asks about being present at any time during a rolling four-week period. Someone arriving before 11pm and staying after 11pm can count in Q1 but not in the benchmark. Reweighting assumes the two measures are comparable enough and cannot fix bias within either group.
  • Q4 measures hypothetical intent after a home-gym closure. It does not measure incremental churn above baseline, fee sensitivity, the effect of having another Corefit nearby, or the impact on new sign-ups. The survey did not directly compare a chain-wide policy with selective closure.
  • Home gym is registration, not necessarily where members train. Site samples are small, and some comments contradict their survey labels about overnight use. Check linked records before acting on site-level results; do not infer local competitor availability from individual comments.
  • The 239 open-text answers illustrate possible effects and can carry multiple codes. They do not establish how prevalent those effects are across the membership. Perceived safety is not the same as a measured change in incidents, and anticipated crowding is not observed crowding.

Next steps

  • researchAudit several months of hourly entries by actual site, cross-site use, and the costs that really disappear with closure. Where available, use exit or occupancy data to capture sessions that run past 11pm.
  • researchSpeak to verified frequent overnight users at candidate sites, especially people working nights. Check whether offered alternatives work with their shifts, travel and membership terms; verify the hours of local competitors.
  • experimentRun a time-limited closure pilot with comparable gyms that stay open 24 hours, after setting thresholds and giving members notice and clear access options.
  • monitorTrack occupancy around 10–11pm and 5–6am, complaints, safety incidents and loss of access throughout the pilot.

Open-text themes it coded

Overnight is the only workable training window because of shift or night work 16Would or probably would switch to another gym, among recent overnight users 19Shorter hours should mean lower fees, or the same fee would no longer be fair 52Expect quieter slots just before closing or after reopening to become busier 31Unstaffed late-night opening feels unsafe or uncomfortable; closure would be reassuring 42Explicitly says they would be unaffected or would not mind, without raising a price or crowding downside 100

The survey it planned

1 screening question and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.

  1. S1

    Do you currently have a Corefit membership?

    One answer
    • Yes
    • No
    • I'm not sure

    Continues if Yes

  2. Q1

    Thinking back to when you first joined Corefit, which of the following, if any, were reasons you chose it? Select all that apply. If you choose ‘None of these’ or ‘I don't remember’, select that answer on its own.

    Any that apply
    • The membership price
    • A convenient location
    • Being able to use the gym at any time of day or night (24-hour opening)
    • A rolling monthly membership rather than a long-term contract
    • The gym equipment or facilities
    • Being able to use more than one Corefit gym
    • A recommendation from someone I know
    • An offer or discount when I joined
    • Another reason
    • None of these
    • I don't remember
  3. Q2

    In September 2026, how many times did you enter a Corefit gym at or after 11pm and before 5am? Include visits to any Corefit gym. Count each visit once, based on the time you entered.

    One answer
    • None
    • Once
    • 2 to 3 times
    • 4 to 7 times
    • 8 to 11 times
    • 12 or more times
    • I'm not sure
    • I wasn't a Corefit member at any point in September 2026
  4. Q3

    In September 2026, on how many days did you enter a Corefit gym before 11pm and stay past 11pm? Include visits to any Corefit gym.

    One answer
    • None
    • One day
    • 2 to 3 days
    • 4 to 7 days
    • 8 to 11 days
    • 12 or more days
    • I'm not sure

    Routing Shown only if Q2 is: None; Once; 2 to 3 times; 4 to 7 times; 8 to 11 times; 12 or more times; I'm not sure

  5. Q4

    Imagine every Corefit gym closed each night from 11pm to 5am. Membership prices and opening hours at other times would stay the same. How would this affect your ability to work out at Corefit at times that suit you?

    One answer
    • It would be much harder
    • It would be a little harder
    • It would make no difference
    • It would be a little easier
    • It would be much easier
    • I'm not sure
  6. Q5

    If every Corefit gym closed each night from 11pm to 5am, how likely would you be to keep your Corefit membership for the first three months after the change?

    One answer
    • I would definitely keep it
    • I would probably keep it
    • I would probably cancel it
    • I would definitely cancel it
    • I'm not sure
  7. Q6

    If every Corefit gym closed each night from 11pm to 5am, what, if anything, would you expect to do differently? Select all that apply. If you choose ‘I wouldn't change what I do’ or ‘I'm not sure’, select that answer on its own.

    Any that apply
    • Move some or all of my Corefit workouts to a different time
    • Switch some or all of my workouts to a gym that isn't part of Corefit
    • Work out at home, outdoors or somewhere else instead of at Corefit
    • Work out less often or stop working out
    • Work out more often
    • Make another change
    • I wouldn't change what I do
    • I'm not sure
  8. Q7

    Now imagine that only your home gym (the gym listed on your Corefit account) closed each night from 11pm to 5am. All other Corefit gyms would stay open 24 hours, and membership prices would stay the same. How would this affect your ability to work out at Corefit at times that suit you?

    One answer
    • It would be much harder
    • It would be a little harder
    • It would make no difference
    • It would be a little easier
    • It would be much easier
    • I'm not sure
  9. Q8

    If only your home gym closed each night from 11pm to 5am and all other Corefit gyms stayed open 24 hours, how likely would you be to keep your Corefit membership for the first three months after the change?

    One answer
    • I would definitely keep it
    • I would probably keep it
    • I would probably cancel it
    • I would definitely cancel it
    • I'm not sure
  10. Q9

    What is your age group?

    One answer
    • Under 18
    • 18 to 24
    • 25 to 34
    • 35 to 44
    • 45 to 54
    • 55 to 64
    • 65 or over
    • Prefer not to say
  11. Q10

    In September 2026, did any of your paid work take place between 11pm and 5am? Include work that covered only part of those hours.

    One answer
    • Yes, at least once a week
    • Yes, but less often than once a week
    • No, I did paid work but not during those hours
    • I didn't do paid work in September 2026
    • I'm not sure
    • Prefer not to say
Sample plan

Send a neutral email invitation and unique survey link to a random sample of current members drawn separately within each of the 14 home gyms. Field shortly after September 2026 to limit recall error. Target about 1,000 eligible completes: 71 per gym, plus one extra at each of six randomly selected gyms. Set invitation counts by expected response rates for each gym; for example, a 20% eligible completion rate would require about 5,000 invitations in total. Use reminders and randomly drawn reserve batches for gyms falling short. Attach home gym and region from the database rather than asking respondents. Randomise the substantive options in Q1, keeping ‘Another reason’, ‘None of these’ and ‘I don't remember’ at the end. Use neutral invitation wording and do not disclose management's preferred outcome. Weight chain and regional estimates to current home-gym membership counts. The 1,000-complete target and the requested per-gym precision cannot both be guaranteed: 71–72 completes gives a worst-case 95% margin of about ±12 percentage points per gym before finite-population correction, assuming simple random sampling. If ±8 points is mandatory, approve a larger sample: 151 completes per gym (2,114 total) before finite-population correction. Recalculate targets using actual gym membership counts: for a gym with N members, the simple-random-sample target is 150.0625 × N / (N + 149.0625), rounded up. Allow for any loss of effective sample size from weighting. These targets apply to proportions based on a full gym sample, not small subgroups, and do not account for nonresponse bias.