Benchmarks / SurveyBench / Should Corefit gyms stop opening 24 hours? / Qwen4 Max

Measured by Spring Prompt

Qwen4 Max: Should Corefit gyms stop opening 24 hours?

The decision: whether to close all 14 gyms between 11pm and 5am, close overnight only at the quietest gyms, or keep every gym open 24 hours. The brief and the data →

Verdict
✗ Not sound
Research score
90 of 100
Analysis rating
1,373
Head to head, this task
won 11 of 13

Why it is not sound

The analysis

  • Reported a material finding the data does not support

Findings the judges found unsupported

  • Best single estimate of stated cancellation risk from closing every gym overnight is ~11.4% of members (~4,400), not the headline 14.6%. Treat this as a ceiling on intent, not a churn forecast: it is hypothetical, unmitigated by any price or access response, and 'neither likely nor unlikely' is the largest single answer (32.3%), i.e. a lot of members have not made up their minds and are persuadable in either direction.The weighted 11.4% is a supported estimate of stated intention, but it is not an established ceiling on actual cancellations. Neither a neutral answer nor the hypothetical nature of the question establishes that respondents are persuadable or provides a numerical upper bound.
  • Roughly three-quarters of the projected churn comes from people who never use the gym overnight. The commercial risk of closure is therefore fairness and brand ('I pay for 24 hours'), not lost visits. This reframes the decision: it is a pricing/positioning decision as much as an operating-hours decision, and a well-designed price or credit response could remove most of the risk without keeping any gym open.The calculation describes the composition of weighted cancellation intentions, not projected churn. Having made no overnight visits in the last four weeks does not mean never using overnight access. There is no cross-tabulation establishing that these respondents' cancellation intentions are caused by fairness or price, or evidence that a price or credit response could remove most of the risk.
  • A small, identifiable core of night-shift members would lose their only possible training window. For them this is loss of the product, not inconvenience, and no price cut will retain them. Overnight usage is bimodal: the typical overnight respondent goes 2-3 times in four weeks, while essentially all heavy (15+) use is night-shift workers. Estimated at roughly 500-1,300 members chain-wide - small, but concentrated in specific gyms and shift employers, and highly vocal.The estimated 500-1,300 members are extrapolations from the 15-plus-visit group under different weighting assumptions, not a measured range for members whose only possible training window is overnight. Heavy use does not establish exclusive dependence, and the survey does not establish their concentration by employer or gym, that they are highly vocal, or that no price response could retain any of them.
  • Closure would push overnight demand into the shoulders - 10pm-11pm and 5am-6am - and damage the experience of a much larger group of members who deliberately train then for quiet. Q4 does not capture this: it asks only about the respondent's own access, so the 11.4% estimate is missing a second-order churn and satisfaction risk. This is the strongest argument for piloting rather than switching off chain-wide.The open text establishes concern about displacement, not that closure would necessarily cause crowding or damage a much larger group's experience. Q4 asks about cancellation following closure generally, not only loss of personal access, so respondents could already have incorporated crowding concerns. The 57.4% arriving during the broad 5am-9am and 5pm-11pm windows cannot be identified as users of the narrow 5am-6am and 10pm-11pm shoulders.
  • 24-hour access is a real but secondary purchase reason - it is the option, not the habit, that most members bought. Answer to the marketing director: expect stated churn of ~11% (~4,400) as an upper bound, concentrated in the ~20% who bought 24h access; price and location are the load-bearing brand claims and give you room to trade hours for value, provided the trade is explicit and visible.No supplied cross-tabulation establishes that cancellation intentions are concentrated among respondents who selected 24-hour access as a joining reason. The weighted joining-reason percentage does not establish that this group accounts for the cancellation risk, and the survey does not demonstrate that trading hours for value will retain them.
  • A blanket price cut is almost as expensive as the churn it is meant to prevent, so do not reach for it chain-wide. A targeted response (retain overnight access where demand exists, offer credits/transfers to affected members) dominates on cost. Finance must supply the actual avoided cost per gym-night before any closure is approved: on illustrative numbers, blanket closure only pays if it saves roughly £200+ per gym per night.The illustrative arithmetic is valid under its assumptions, but targeted compensation is not shown to dominate on cost, and a blanket discount is not shown to avert the assumed cancellations. Without actual churn, revenue and avoided-cost evidence, approximately £210 per gym-night is a scenario threshold, not an established requirement for closure to pay.

Scorecard

Numbers 11 of 11 right

QuestionIts answerTrue
What percentage of respondents reported at least one visit to a Corefit gym between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks?✓14.9%14.9%
What percentage of all respondents said they would be likely (fairly or very) to cancel their membership if their home gym closed between 11pm and 5am?✓14.6%14.6%
Among respondents who reported at least one visit between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks, what percentage said they would be likely (fairly or very) to cancel?✓45.8%45.8%
Weighted so that respondents with at least one visit between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks count as 6% of members (the door-entry figure) and the rest as 94%, what percentage would be likely (fairly or very) to cancel?✓11.4%11.4%
If the weighted share likely to cancel were applied to all 38,600 members, about how many members would that be?✓4,3994,383
Among respondents who reported at least one visit between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks, in which band of the Q1 table does the median number of visits fall? Give the lowest value of that band (for example 4 for '4 to 7').✓22
What is the 95% margin of error, in percentage points, on the unweighted share of respondents who reported at least one visit between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks?✓2.3 points2.27 points
Is the difference between North West England and North East England respondents in the share likely (fairly or very) to cancel statistically significant at the 95% level? (1 for yes, 0 for no)✓NoNo
How many of the open-text answers say that 11pm to 5am is the only time the respondent can train because they work shifts or nights?✓1616
How many of the open-text answers from respondents who visited between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks say they would move to another gym?✓1919
What percentage of the members invited completed the survey?✓8%8%

Traps in the data 8 of 8 handled

  • ✓14.9% of respondents report at least one visit between 11pm and 5am in the last four weeks, against 6% of members in the door-entry records: members with a stake in the overnight hours were more likely to respond. Unweighted, 14.6% say they would be likely to cancel; weighted to the 6%, 11.4%.
  • ✓'Likely to cancel' answers (45.8% of overnight users, 14.6% overall) are stated intentions about a hypothetical closure, asked straight after members were invited to think about it.
  • ✓The mean number of overnight visits among overnight users (7.4) is pulled up by night-shift workers who come almost daily; the median is in the '2 to 3' band.
  • ✓The operations director believes almost nobody uses the gyms overnight. Partly true: 6% of members in the door-entry records (about 2,316 people). But night-shift workers (5.9% of respondents) mostly train between 11pm and 5am (77.8% of those who visited overnight usually arrive then) and are the most likely to say they would cancel.
  • ✓At Wakefield Calder Park (base 11), 54.5% of respondents used the gym overnight and 27.3% say they would be likely to cancel.
  • ✓North West England respondents (base 229) look more likely to cancel than North East England respondents (base 220): 19.2% against 13.6%, a gap that is not statistically significant at 95%.
  • ✓Only 950 of 11,900 invited members completed (about 8%); those who responded differ from those who did not, as the overnight-use skew shows.
  • ✓Only current members were surveyed: people who joined for 24-hour access and have since left, and people who would join only because of it, are missing, so the survey cannot show what 24-hour opening does for recruitment or the brand; and night-shift workers are a small group whose answers carry little weight in the totals even though they depend on the hours.

The analysis

Recommendation

Do not close all 14 gyms overnight now, and do not carve out the North West. Keep 24-hour opening as the default while you run a controlled closure pilot at a small number of genuinely quiet gyms, chosen from door-entry data rather than from this survey. Direct answers: (1) Operations director - you are right that usage is tiny (6% of members, ~2,316, in September; the median overnight user goes only 2-3 times in four weeks), but 'almost nobody uses it' is the wrong test. The modelled churn is ~11.4% (~4,400 members), and about three-quarters of it sits with people who never go overnight and object on fairness grounds. Usage volume alone does not justify a chain-wide switch-off. (2) Marketing director - plan against a stated-intent ceiling of ~11% (~4,400), with actual churn probably materially lower; 24-hour access was a joining reason for ~20% of members on a corrected basis (59% of overnight users, 18% of everyone else), so the asset at risk is the option and the sense of a fair deal, not nightly footfall. Price and location remain the dominant reasons people joined (69% and 63%), which gives you room to trade hours for visible value - but a blanket £2/month cut costs ~£926k/year, nearly as much as the ~£1.06m/year of churn it would avert, so any compensation must be targeted, not chain-wide. (3) Regional manager - no. North West 19.2% vs North East 13.6% is a 5.6pp gap on bases of 229 and 220 (p~0.11); it is noise, and overnight use is identical in the two regions (14.0% vs 15.0%). Set policy gym by gym on behavioural data, not by region. Two things must be protected in any pilot: the ~500-1,300 near-daily night-shift members for whom 11pm-5am is the only possible window (they cannot be retained by a discount, only by access), and the far larger group who buy quiet at 5am and 10pm and who will absorb the displaced demand. Also put the untested third option on the table - staffing or restricting overnight access rather than closing - because 42 of 239 open-text answers object to unstaffed hours specifically, not to the gym being open.

What would change it

Move to chain-wide closure if: (a) 6-12 months of gym-by-hour door data show overnight demand is negligible at most sites AND the affected members have a 24-hour Corefit within a realistic travel distance; (b) a matched-control pilot shows net incremental cancellations at or below the level finance says the avoided cost covers (illustratively, closure needs to save ~£210 per gym-night to break even against 4,400 lost members at ~£20/month - replace both numbers with actual ARPU and avoided cost); (c) a price/value trade-off test shows a small, targeted credit or fee change neutralises the fairness objection among non-users; and (d) shoulder-hour occupancy monitoring shows no material satisfaction or churn damage at 5am-6am and 10pm-11pm. Keep 24 hours (or staff/restrict rather than close) if: the door data show a hard core of night-shift members with no alternative site; the pilot shows churn materially above the break-even threshold or a measurable shoulder-hour backlash; competitor mapping shows a 24-hour rival within walking distance of the affected gyms; or insurers/incident data make unstaffed opening, rather than opening itself, the real problem. A verified Wakefield membership count that shows the 54.5% figure was an artefact of 11 respondents would also remove the strongest apparent case for a site-specific exception.

Findings

  1. The operations director is right that overnight use is small, but the survey overstates it by roughly 2.5x. Use the door-entry figure (6%, ~2,316 members) for sizing, not the survey's 14.9%. The gap is far too big to be sampling noise, so it is non-response/self-report bias: overnight users were much more likely to answer a survey about overnight opening.

    High confidenceBase 950

    Q1 net at least one overnight visit = 14.9% of 950 (95% MoE +/-2.3pp) vs door records 6% of 38,600 (2,316 members) in September. 14.9% is ~2.5x 6%; the confidence interval (12.6%-17.2%) does not come close to 6%.

  2. Best single estimate of stated cancellation risk from closing every gym overnight is ~11.4% of members (~4,400), not the headline 14.6%. Treat this as a ceiling on intent, not a churn forecast: it is hypothetical, unmitigated by any price or access response, and 'neither likely nor unlikely' is the largest single answer (32.3%), i.e. a lot of members have not made up their minds and are persuadable in either direction.

    Medium confidenceBase 950

    Q4 net likely: 45.8% of 142 overnight visitors and 9.2% of 808 non-visitors; reweighting to 6%/94% gives 0.06x45.8 + 0.94x9.2 = 11.4%; x38,600 = ~4,399. Unweighted total 14.6% of 950. Neither = 32.3%; very likely only 6.1%.

  3. Roughly three-quarters of the projected churn comes from people who never use the gym overnight. The commercial risk of closure is therefore fairness and brand ('I pay for 24 hours'), not lost visits. This reframes the decision: it is a pricing/positioning decision as much as an operating-hours decision, and a well-designed price or credit response could remove most of the risk without keeping any gym open.

    Medium confidenceBase 808

    Of the 11.4 weighted points, 8.6pp (0.94 x 9.2%) sits with non-visitors = ~3,340 of the ~4,400; only ~2.7pp (~1,060) with overnight visitors. In Q3, 43 of the 52 price-reduction answers came from respondents with no overnight visits (e.g. M053 'I joined a 24 hour gym and pay for that', M089, M465). Q5: 17.8% of the 808 non-visitors still named 'Open 24 hours' as a joining reason.

  4. A small, identifiable core of night-shift members would lose their only possible training window. For them this is loss of the product, not inconvenience, and no price cut will retain them. Overnight usage is bimodal: the typical overnight respondent goes 2-3 times in four weeks, while essentially all heavy (15+) use is night-shift workers. Estimated at roughly 500-1,300 members chain-wide - small, but concentrated in specific gyms and shift employers, and highly vocal.

    High confidenceBase 56

    Q1 median among the 142 overnight visitors falls in '2 to 3' while the mean is 7.4; 3.4% of 950 (32 respondents) report 15+ visits and all 32 sit in the night-shift column (57.1% of 56). Night-shift column: 80.4% overnight use, 48.2% likely to cancel (n=56). 16 Q3 answers state overnight is the only window because of shifts/nights (M162, M166, M222, M300, M321, M492, M551, M568, M592, M593, M685, M695, M752, M793, M889, M924). Scaling 32/950 by the 6%/14.9% correction gives ~1.3% of members (~520); unweighted would be ~1,310.

  5. There is no statistical basis for a North West exception. Answer to the regional manager: do not set opening-hours policy by region. The 5.6pp gap is within noise, region is only a proxy for the gym and its shift-worker/competitor mix, and the same logic would not explain why Scotland has the highest overnight use but mid-level churn intent.

    High confidenceBase 449

    Q4 net likely: North West 19.2% (n=229) vs North East 13.6% (n=220); difference 5.6pp, SE 3.5pp, z=1.61, p~0.11 (not significant at 95%). Overnight use is essentially identical: NW 14.0%, NE 15.0%. Scotland highest overnight use 19.3% (n=135) with 14.8% likely to cancel.

  6. Do not name individual gyms for closure from this survey. Gym-level bases are too small to rank, and Wakefield Calder Park's alarming figures rest on 11 people (6 overnight users). Its 1.2% share of the sample also needs checking against the membership database - if Wakefield is genuinely that small, its economics are a separate question; if not, something is wrong with the sample or the Q6 coding.

    High confidenceBase 11

    Wakefield: 54.5% overnight and 27.3% likely to cancel on base 11 (MoE roughly +/-29pp on the overnight figure). All other gym bases are 61-81, giving MoEs of roughly +/-8-11pp on cancellation; the apparent spread (Bradford 6.6% to Manchester Ancoats 21.0%) is largely what you would expect from noise across 14 comparisons.

  7. Closure would push overnight demand into the shoulders - 10pm-11pm and 5am-6am - and damage the experience of a much larger group of members who deliberately train then for quiet. Q4 does not capture this: it asks only about the respondent's own access, so the 11.4% estimate is missing a second-order churn and satisfaction risk. This is the strongest argument for piloting rather than switching off chain-wide.

    Medium confidenceBase 239

    31 Q3 answers raise displacement/crowding, 28 of them from respondents with no overnight visits (M028, M057, M058, M119, M152, M177, M190, M191, M208, M218, M264, M324, M361, M445, M454, M509, M529, M533, M557, M588, M699, M734, M739, M804, M812, M832, M849, M918). Q2: 22.0% of 950 usually arrive 5am-9am and 35.4% 5pm-11pm - the exposed shoulders are ~57% of the membership. Note 3 of the crowding answers are from overnight visitors themselves (M185, M329, M900).

  8. A substantial group of non-users would actively welcome closure because unstaffed overnight opening makes them feel unsafe. This is a genuine co-benefit and a comms asset - but note what they are objecting to is the absence of staff, not the opening hours. 'Staff the overnight hours' or 'staffed access only' is an untested third option that might satisfy both this group and the night-shift core.

    Medium confidenceBase 239

    42 of 239 Q3 answers support closure on safety/unstaffed grounds, all from respondents with no overnight visits (e.g. M009, M285 'especially as a woman on my own', M528, M597, M868). No question in the survey tested staffing levels, a shorter closure window, or restricted overnight access.

  9. 24-hour access is a real but secondary purchase reason - it is the option, not the habit, that most members bought. Answer to the marketing director: expect stated churn of ~11% (~4,400) as an upper bound, concentrated in the ~20% who bought 24h access; price and location are the load-bearing brand claims and give you room to trade hours for value, provided the trade is explicit and visible.

    Medium confidenceBase 950

    Q5: Open 24 hours 24.0% of 950 (59.2% of 142 overnight visitors vs 17.8% of 808 non-visitors); reweighted to 6%/94% = ~20.3%. Low price 68.9%, close to home/work 62.6%, no fixed-term contract 38.9%. 19 Q3 answers from overnight visitors name a move to another gym (M224, M282, M302, M459, M467, M492, M577, M623, M625, M674, M688, M713, M752, M769, M800, M823, M916, M924, M942), several naming specific 24h competitors (PureGym, The Gym Group, Anytime Fitness).

  10. A blanket price cut is almost as expensive as the churn it is meant to prevent, so do not reach for it chain-wide. A targeted response (retain overnight access where demand exists, offer credits/transfers to affected members) dominates on cost. Finance must supply the actual avoided cost per gym-night before any closure is approved: on illustrative numbers, blanket closure only pays if it saves roughly £200+ per gym per night.

    Low confidenceBase 950

    Illustrative ARPU ~£20/month (Q3 quotes £17 M429, £18 M674, £19.99 M160, £22 M100). 4,400 lost members x £20 x 12 = ~£1.06m/year at risk; break-even = ~£88k/month across 14 gyms = ~£6.3k per gym per month = ~£210 per gym-night. A £2/month chain-wide discount costs 38,600 x £2 x 12 = ~£926k/year - i.e. it consumes nearly all of the churn saving. No cost, staffing, energy, insurance or occupancy data was supplied with this research.

  11. The 6% door-entry figure is a one-month snapshot and probably understates how many members rely on overnight access at some point in the year, because rotas rotate. Members with variable hours are a second at-risk group, and a September-only count will miss night-shift workers who were on days that month. Size the at-risk population from 6-12 months of door data, not one month.

    Medium confidenceBase 121

    Q7: 12.7% of 950 have hours that vary week to week (n=121), of whom 18.2% report overnight visits and 17.4% are likely to cancel; 5.9% work shifts including nights (n=56). Q1 asks about the last four weeks (mid-Sept to mid-Oct) while the door figure is September only. Several night-shift respondents report no overnight visits at all (M838, M914), consistent with rotation.

  12. The evidence base is thin enough that it should inform the design of a pilot, not the final closure decision. An 8% completion rate with weighting on a single variable cannot rule out attitude bias, and the open text contains internal contradictions that make gym-level attribution unsafe.

    High confidenceBase 950

    950 completes from 11,900 invited = 8.0% (1,031 started, 92% of starters finished, median 4m30s). Q3 answered by only 239 of 950 (25%), self-selected. 16+ open-text answers reference a different town from the Q6 home gym (M059 Leeds->Glasgow, M100 Leeds->Glasgow, M118 Salford->Newcastle, M121 Preston->Leeds, M178 Salford->Leith, M224 Edinburgh->Sheffield, M321 Hull->Motherwell, M429 Leeds->Preston, M459/M467, M551 Sheffield->Glasgow, M625 Leeds->Sheffield, M685 Hull->Leeds, M713 Sheffield->Glasgow, M800 Salford->Leith, M823 Newcastle->Leeds). Some respondents flagged as overnight visitors say they never go overnight (M034, M305, M313, M735).

Caveats

  • Response rate is 8.0% (950 of 11,900 invited; 1,031 started). Non-response bias is the dominant risk, and the survey demonstrably over-recruits overnight users (14.9% vs 6% on door records). All tables are unweighted; only the overnight/non-overnight split has been corrected here. Attitudes within each group may still be biased.
  • The 11.4% / ~4,400 figure is stated intention in response to a hypothetical, with no price cut, no notice period and no alternative offered. Stated churn normally over-states behaviour, often by half or more; but rolling monthly membership means very low switching friction, so the usual 'intent discount' should be smaller than for a fixed-term gym. Treat it as a planning ceiling, not a forecast, and do not put it in a business case as a point estimate.
  • Q4 measures only the effect on the respondent's own access. It cannot capture churn caused by crowding at 5am/10pm, which 31 open-text answers raise, nor churn among members who join later on a weaker 24-hour brand promise. The 11.4% is therefore not a complete risk estimate in either direction.
  • Q3 was answered by only 239 of 950 (25%), self-selected. Theme counts describe what is on respondents' minds, not prevalence; never convert them into percentages of members.
  • Gym-level bases are 61-81 except Wakefield Calder Park (11). Gym MoEs are roughly +/-8-11pp on cancellation and worse for Wakefield; the 14-gym ranking is not statistically defensible and no gym should be selected for closure on it. Wakefield's 1.2% sample share needs reconciling with the membership database.
  • The North West vs North East comparison (and any other subgroup gap here) is one of many possible comparisons; the 5.6pp gap is not significant (p~0.11) and should not be acted on. Region is also confounded with gym, urban competitor density and shift-employer mix.
  • The door-entry benchmark is a single month (September) and counts members, not visits or hours. Rotating rotas mean the population that ever depends on overnight access over a year is larger than 6%; the survey's four-week window is also not exactly September.
  • Internal inconsistencies in the data: at least 16 open-text answers name a town that contradicts the Q6 home gym, and several respondents coded as overnight visitors say they never go overnight (M034, M305, M313, M735). Some 'unsafe/unstaffed' comments may reflect assumption rather than experience - the survey never stated whether overnight hours are staffed. Do not use open-text locations to attribute views to specific gyms.
  • Q5 is recall of joining motives, with 29.9% of members of 2+ years' standing; 'Can't remember' is 3.5% overall but 4.0% among non-visitors. The 24-hour figure is a claimed reason, not a measure of what would actually drive switching.
  • No cost, occupancy, staffing, energy, insurance or incident data accompanied this research, and no data on 24-hour competitor proximity per gym. The survey alone cannot tell you whether closure is profitable - only what members say they would do.
  • The options tested were binary (close 11pm-5am everywhere, or not). Shorter closure windows, staffed overnight access, member-only app access, or grandfathering existing overnight users were not tested and may dominate both.

Next steps

  • researchExtract 6-12 months of door-entry data by gym, hour and member, and cross-tab against shift-pattern and tenure. Produce, per gym: unique overnight members per month and per year, visits per overnight member, share of members whose overnight use is near-daily (15+/4 weeks), and the distance to the nearest other 24-hour Corefit and to the nearest 24-hour competitor.
  • decisionAsk finance for the fully-loaded avoided cost of closing 11pm-5am per gym per night (energy, lighting/HVAC, cleaning, security, maintenance, insurance, any overnight staffing) and current ARPU by gym, then compute the break-even number of lost members per gym.
  • experimentRun an 8-12 week closure pilot at 3-4 of the lowest-overnight-demand gyms from the door data, with matched control gyms (matched on overnight demand, membership size, tenure mix and competitor proximity). Give 6-8 weeks' notice, guarantee free transfer/access rights to the nearest 24-hour Corefit, and proactively contact every member with any overnight entry in the last 6 months.
  • monitorMonitor hourly occupancy and equipment-wait times at 5am-6am and 10pm-11pm in pilot and control gyms throughout, plus satisfaction and cancellation reasons among members who use those shoulders.
  • researchRun a price/value trade-off study on non-overnight users (e.g. Gabor-Granger or a small conjoint: 24-hour access vs £1/£2/£3 monthly reduction vs credit), with a booster sample of actual overnight users identified from door records, including night-shift and variable-hours members and Wakefield.
  • researchDesign and cost two untested alternatives before the final decision: (a) staffed or supervised overnight access, (b) a shorter closure window (e.g. 1am-4am) or app-gated member-only overnight access with grandfathering for existing overnight users.
  • decisionTake the decision in principle now: no chain-wide closure and no region-based exception this quarter; confirm 24-hour opening as the default and communicate that a small, evidence-led pilot is underway with access protected for members who train overnight.
  • monitorBuild a standing overnight dashboard (unique overnight members per gym per month, near-daily users, shoulder-hour occupancy, cancellation rate by overnight-use segment) and re-baseline the member survey with weighting to the membership database on overnight use, gym, tenure and region.

Open-text themes it coded

No personal impact - does not use the overnight hours 90Expects a lower monthly fee in return for reduced hours (fairness of the deal) 52Welcomes closure because unstaffed overnight opening feels unsafe 42Displacement: overnight users would crowd my quiet 10pm-11pm or 5am-6am slot 31Shift/night worker: 11pm-5am is my only possible training window, so closure ends my gym use 16Would cancel or move to another (24-hour) gym 2024-hour access is part of what I joined for / am paying for (brand and option value) 6

The survey it planned

2 screening questions and 10 questions, as the model wrote them.

  1. S1

    Are you currently a Corefit member with an active membership?

    One answer
    • Yes, my membership is active
    • No – I have cancelled or my membership has ended
    • Not sure

    Continues if Yes, my membership is active

  2. S2

    Which Corefit gym do you use most often at the moment? If you use several equally, please pick the one you used most recently. (The home gym on your membership record is [HOME GYM NAME].)

    One answer
    • [GYM 01 NAME]
    • [GYM 02 NAME]
    • [GYM 03 NAME]
    • [GYM 04 NAME]
    • [GYM 05 NAME]
    • [GYM 06 NAME]
    • [GYM 07 NAME]
    • [GYM 08 NAME]
    • [GYM 09 NAME]
    • [GYM 10 NAME]
    • [GYM 11 NAME]
    • [GYM 12 NAME]
    • [GYM 13 NAME]
    • [GYM 14 NAME]

    Continues if [GYM 01 NAME]; [GYM 02 NAME]; [GYM 03 NAME]; [GYM 04 NAME]; [GYM 05 NAME]; [GYM 06 NAME]; [GYM 07 NAME]; [GYM 08 NAME]; [GYM 09 NAME]; [GYM 10 NAME]; [GYM 11 NAME]; [GYM 12 NAME]; [GYM 13 NAME]; [GYM 14 NAME]

  3. Q1

    Thinking back to when you joined Corefit, which of these were reasons for choosing it? Please select all that apply.

    Any that apply
    • Low monthly price
    • No long contract – rolling monthly membership
    • Close to home
    • Close to work, school or college
    • Open 24 hours a day
    • The equipment and facilities
    • It felt welcoming / not intimidating
    • Classes or group sessions
    • Parking or transport links
    • Recommended by a friend or family member
    • It was the only gym available to me
    • Other reason (please tell us)
    • Can't remember
  4. Q2

    And which ONE of those was the most important reason for choosing Corefit?

    One answer
    • Low monthly price
    • No long contract – rolling monthly membership
    • Close to home
    • Close to work, school or college
    • Open 24 hours a day
    • The equipment and facilities
    • It felt welcoming / not intimidating
    • Classes or group sessions
    • Parking or transport links
    • Recommended by a friend or family member
    • It was the only gym available to me
    • Other reason
    • Can't remember
  5. Q3

    In the last 3 months, how often have you been into a Corefit gym at any time between 11pm and 5am? Please count any visit, even a short one.

    One answer
    • Not once in the last 3 months
    • Once or twice in total
    • About once a month
    • 2 or 3 times a month
    • About once a week
    • 2 or 3 times a week
    • 4 or more times a week
    • Not sure / can't remember
  6. Q4

    Which Corefit gym or gyms have you used between 11pm and 5am in the last 3 months? Please select all that apply.

    Any that apply
    • [GYM 01 NAME]
    • [GYM 02 NAME]
    • [GYM 03 NAME]
    • [GYM 04 NAME]
    • [GYM 05 NAME]
    • [GYM 06 NAME]
    • [GYM 07 NAME]
    • [GYM 08 NAME]
    • [GYM 09 NAME]
    • [GYM 10 NAME]
    • [GYM 11 NAME]
    • [GYM 12 NAME]
    • [GYM 13 NAME]
    • [GYM 14 NAME]
    • Can't remember which gym

    Routing Shown only if Q3 is: Once or twice in total; About once a month; 2 or 3 times a month; About once a week; 2 or 3 times a week; 4 or more times a week

  7. Q5

    What are the reasons you train between 11pm and 5am? Please select all that apply.

    Any that apply
    • Work or shift times mean it is the only time I can train
    • Childcare or caring responsibilities
    • The gym is quieter at that time
    • Equipment is free / no waiting
    • I prefer training at night
    • It fits my sleep pattern
    • I train with someone who goes at that time
    • Travel or commute times
    • Other reason (please tell us)

    Routing Shown only if Q3 is: Once or twice in total; About once a month; 2 or 3 times a month; About once a week; 2 or 3 times a week; 4 or more times a week

  8. Q6

    If your gym were closed between 11pm and 5am, could you move those sessions to other times of day?

    One answer
    • Yes – I could train at other times just as easily
    • Yes – but it would be less convenient
    • Only some of them – I would lose some training sessions
    • No – I would not be able to train at Corefit at all
    • Don't know

    Routing Shown only if Q3 is: Once or twice in total; About once a month; 2 or 3 times a month; About once a week; 2 or 3 times a week; 4 or more times a week

  9. Q7

    Now imagine Corefit closed every gym between 11pm and 5am, with all other opening hours unchanged. Which ONE of these comes closest to what you would most likely do?

    One answer
    • Keep my membership and train just as often, at other times
    • Keep my membership but train less often
    • Keep my membership for now, but start looking for another gym
    • Freeze or pause my membership
    • Cancel my membership and join another gym
    • Cancel my membership and stop training at a gym
    • Don't know
  10. Q8

    How important is it to you personally that Corefit is open between 11pm and 5am, whether or not you use those hours at the moment?

    Scale

    Scale 1-5: Not at all important to Essential – I need it

  11. Q9

    Which of these best describes your usual working pattern?

    One answer
    • Regular daytime hours (roughly 9am to 5pm)
    • Early starts (before 7am)
    • Late or evening shifts (finishing after 10pm)
    • Night shifts (working through the night)
    • Rotating or changing shifts
    • Flexible hours / self-employed
    • Full-time student
    • Not in paid work at the moment (including retired, unemployed, full-time caring)
    • Prefer not to say
  12. Q10

    Which age band are you in?

    One answer
    • 16–24
    • 25–34
    • 35–44
    • 45–54
    • 55–64
    • 65 or over
    • Prefer not to say
Sample plan

FRAME: all 38,600 active members on the membership database (one record per member, deduplicated; staff/test/lapsed accounts removed). Every member has an email and a home gym, so the frame covers the whole population and no on-site or self-selected recruitment is used. FIELDWORK: online, October 2026, 14 days in field, invitation plus reminders on day 4 and day 9, small prize-draw incentive to lift response. Invitation and questionnaire are worded neutrally ('a review of Corefit opening hours'): no mention of a proposed closure, of the £310,000 cost, or of the operations director's view. Response options are balanced (Q7 includes 'train just as often' and Q8 allows 'not at all important'), reason lists in Q1/Q2 are randomised with 'Other' and 'Can't remember' anchored last, and the joining-reason questions come BEFORE any question mentioning 11pm–5am so that 24-hour opening is not primed. The stakeholder's hypothesis is treated as one possible finding, not a target; the analysis plan is agreed and written down before fieldwork. STRATIFICATION AND SAMPLE SIZE: stratified random sample by home gym (14 strata) crossed with an overnight-use flag taken from door-entry records for the last 3 months (July–September 2026; September alone gives 6%). The board's precision requirement drives the sample size: ±8pp at 95% for a worst-case 50% proportion needs n=151 per gym (about 143 after the finite-population correction for an average gym of ~2,757 members). The brief's 1,000 completes would give only ~71 per gym, i.e. about ±11.6pp, so we will NOT deliver 1,000. Target 170 completes per gym = ~2,380 completes (round to 2,400), hard minimum 150 per gym. If the budget is fixed at 1,000 completes, the board must choose in advance between (a) accepting ±11–12pp per gym, or (b) reporting only 4–5 pooled gym clusters/regions at ±8pp; we will not present 1,000 completes as gym-level ±8pp. OVERNIGHT USERS: they are a small, decision-critical subgroup, so we census-invite EVERY member with at least one 11pm–5am door entry in the last 3 months (roughly 3,000–4,000 people, more than the 2,316 implied by September alone) and take a stratified random sample of the remaining members. Expect ~500–700 overnight-user completes and ~1,700–1,900 non-user completes. Even a census of invitations gives only ~30–50 overnight-user completes per gym (±14–18pp), so per-gym estimates for overnight users CANNOT meet ±8pp; this limitation is stated to the board up front. Overnight incidence and volume per gym are therefore taken from door-entry records (a full census, no sampling error), and survey estimates about overnight users are reported at chain and region level, with gym-level figures shown only as indicative with intervals. INVITATION VOLUME: assuming ~12% response among non-flagged members and ~20% among flagged overnight users, about 18,000–20,000 invitations are needed. Invite all members at gyms with fewer than ~1,500 members; random-sample within larger gyms. Monitor completes per stratum daily and top up with fresh random invitations in lagging strata (never convenience substitutes or open links). If a small gym still cannot reach 150 completes after census invitation plus reminders and an extended window, flag that gym's precision explicitly rather than silently pooling it. QUOTAS: soft quota of 170 completes per home gym (min 150) and, within each gym, aim for at least 25 completes from door-flagged overnight users where the flag population allows; no respondent is screened out to fill a quota. WEIGHTING: design weights for the unequal sampling fractions (gym stratum x overnight flag), then post-stratify/rake to database totals for gym, overnight flag, age band and membership tenure. All reported figures are weighted, with unweighted bases shown. DATA QUALITY: remove duplicates and speeders (<40% of median duration), drop straight-liners on Q1/Q8 combinations that are logically impossible, and cross-check self-reported overnight use (Q3) against each respondent's own door-entry record to quantify over/under-reporting; report the calibration rather than assuming either source is truth. TIMING: non-users see 7 questions (~3 minutes), overnight users see all 10 (~5 minutes); median completion targeted under 6 minutes, verified in a 20-member soft launch before main fieldwork.