Benchmarks / DeckBench / Hearthside Coffee
Measured by Spring Prompt
Inkling 2 Mini: Manchester store investment review
For the board of directors (non-executives and the chief executive). The decision it supports: whether to approve £480k of capital for a Manchester store.
- Verdict
- Not presentable
- Deck rating
- 792
- Slides
- 7 (brief: 5-8)
- Design quality
- 64%
Why it is not presentable
- Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
- Did not give the analysis's recommendation within the first two slides
- Made a material claim the analysis does not support
- A slide the judges rated as needing work
In detail
- Slide 4: “Manchester at ~£2,380/day would sit between Leeds and Sheffield — no better and no worse than two of four existing stores.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 4: “Leeds is the outlier at 7.0% — half of York's 18.0%.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 4: “Leeds is the only store with double-digit staff-turnover losses.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 5: “The Leeds pattern is heavy staffing for flat trading.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 6: “A high-seat, staff-heavy model repeats the Leeds pattern.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “The smaller unit achieves 30-month payback on the same ~£2,380/day adjusted run-rate.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “The smaller unit provides lower exposure to the Leeds staffing pattern.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 3: “The base case fails the board's 36-month rule (the base case as submitted pays back in 34 months; only the adjusted case fails)” is not supported by the analysis.