Benchmarks / DeckBench / Hearthside Coffee

Measured by Spring Prompt

Inkling 2 Mini: Manchester store investment review

For the board of directors (non-executives and the chief executive). The decision it supports: whether to approve £480k of capital for a Manchester store.

Verdict
Not presentable
Deck rating
792
Slides
7 (brief: 5-8)
Design quality
64%

Why it is not presentable

  • Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
  • Did not give the analysis's recommendation within the first two slides
  • Made a material claim the analysis does not support
  • A slide the judges rated as needing work

In detail

  • Slide 4: “Manchester at ~£2,380/day would sit between Leeds and Sheffield — no better and no worse than two of four existing stores.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 4: “Leeds is the outlier at 7.0% — half of York's 18.0%.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 4: “Leeds is the only store with double-digit staff-turnover losses.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 5: “The Leeds pattern is heavy staffing for flat trading.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 6: “A high-seat, staff-heavy model repeats the Leeds pattern.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 7: “The smaller unit achieves 30-month payback on the same ~£2,380/day adjusted run-rate.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 7: “The smaller unit provides lower exposure to the Leeds staffing pattern.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 3: “The base case fails the board's 36-month rule (the base case as submitted pays back in 34 months; only the adjusted case fails)” is not supported by the analysis.
  1. Slide 1 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 1Download slide imagePolished
  2. Slide 2 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 2Download slide imagePolished All bars share one colour, so nothing highlights the as-run vs adjusted pop-up comparison against the base case
  3. Slide 3 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 3Download slide imageAcceptable The headline says the base case fails, while the prominent 34-month figure and supporting text say it passes. The headline needs to distinguish the adjusted case so the visual message is unambiguous.Large empty gap between the short table and the callout box on the left
  4. Slide 4 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 4Download slide imageNeeds work The final table header breaks 'Turnover' mid-word into 'Turnov' and 'er'; widen the column or use a deliberate two-line label.The 'Turnover' column header breaks mid-word into 'Turnov / er'
  5. Slide 5 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 5Download slide imageAcceptable The table and chart repeat the turnover figures without highlighting Leeds, missing an opportunity to direct attention to the central comparison.The '74%' data label touches the chart title 'Staff turnover, FY2025'
  6. Slide 6 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 6Download slide imageAcceptable Four similarly weighted prose cards require reading rather than making the key risks immediately scannable; the critical figures lack emphasis.The cards are mostly empty in their lower halves, wasting space
  7. Slide 7 of Inkling 2 Mini's deck
    Slide 7Download slide imagePolished The numbers 01 and 02 sit higher than their text lines, so they are misaligned with the text baselines