Benchmarks / DeckBench / Northgate Homes
Measured by Spring Prompt
Inkling 2 Mini: Responsive repairs: in-house team or renewed contract
For the board of trustees of a housing association, including two tenant board members. The decision it supports: whether to approve £1.2m to set up an in-house repairs team or renew the contract.
- Verdict
- Not presentable
- Deck rating
- 792
- Slides
- 8 (brief: 6-9)
- Design quality
- 75%
Why it is not presentable
- Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
- Made a material claim the analysis does not support
In detail
- Slide 6: “If the in-house team doesn't perform, the saving disappears — which is why the ask is a 12-month bridging contract.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “If in-house fails, the bridging contract keeps the board covered; it is the safety net.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 8: “The bridging contract is in place until month 12, so the board is never without a provider.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “What the chair will press: renewal avoids a £1.2m gamble; the 3-year payback assumes the new team performs at the claimed running cost. This replaces the chair's actual stated view, that the backlog is mostly down to the October system change, and the analysis's rebuttal of it.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “If the team is not performing by month 12, renew — and we have told the board that at the start.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “12-month bridging contract at performance targets — review in September 2026. This is inconsistent with a 12-month bridge starting when the contract ends in September 2026.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 7: “WHAT THE CHAIR WILL PRESS: Renewal avoids a £1.2m gamble... The 3-year payback assumes... The failure mode matters...” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 1: A body text box set at 10.5 pt, too small to read